About

Showing posts with label blogosphere. Show all posts
Showing posts with label blogosphere. Show all posts

A clarification- Surly Amy

8/21 Update: The post with Amy's address -- although it is easily found because she divulges her real name, the town she lives in, and affixes her address to her business -- has been edited to remove the address as per my request. Again, this was not a 'doc drop,' a threat, or anything similar. 

--

Following a recent post authored by 'Lousy Canuck' at Freethought Blogs (and another by Stephanie Zvan), I've been reading many nasty comments and receiving many nasty messages from fans of 'Surly Amy.' I am being painted as nothing more than a malicious person who is leading the charge of a bullying campaign. People are claiming that my intentions are to 'ruin the business of Amy' and that I filed a DMCA counter-claim to discover the real life info of 'Surly Amy' (for whatever end I do not know) to just name two things.

It's quite strange that people are claiming that my blogging efforts are intended to (and somehow can) bring financial ruin on 'Surly Amy.' Prior to the DMCA I received, I authored two blog posts offering criticism of 'Surly Amy's' ideas and in no way, shape or form, did I urge people to boycott her or launch some vast campaign to inflict damage upon her. People are going to buy her jewelry, I would think, regardless of what bloggers have to report on what she said about conference policies or following parody accounts on Twitter... I simply disagreed with what she said and offered criticism of her ideas just like almost every other blogger does on the internet when they disagree with something someone said. Amy is a public figure. She and others should expect this...and they should be able to withstand criticism of ideas.

It's even more bizarre that people claimed that I filed a counter DMCA in order to get the personal details of 'Surly Amy.' To dispel this myth amongst a forum community I chat with, I explained that her personal details are already public and can be easily found via her trademarks (one can look at a trademark registry and find the info). I posted those details rather than -- as I would now -- simply noting that the information was public (even though people can, as I said, easily find the info).

It has come to my attention that many people on Twitter (and even some in blog comments here who have never posted on my content) have chided me for posting the address of 'Surly Amy' and have said some really nasty things. I did not present the address with any malicious intent (I even noted it wasn't a threat) and regret that people believe that it was posted in that fashion.

Instead of inquiring as to why the address was posted or looking at the context surrounding the post, people jumped to a conclusion -- likely because they unjustifiably hold preset notions of me being a horrible person -- that it was done with malicious intent. It seems that people are trying really hard to weave a malicious narrative about me with no concern of what is actually the case or for my welfare. This is regrettable.

Although I am quite upset concerning the DMCA notice and, of course, still disagree with 'Surly Amy' on many issues, I mean -- as should be obvious and the fair assumption -- no ill-will, physical harm, or anything like that. It's a shame that the DMCA was even filed as all of this 'drama' could have been avoided if 'Surly Amy' or whomever sent the DMCA ignored the post or simply sent me an e-mail asking for the image to be removed or for better attribution (even though I offered attribution).

The drama continues on Freethought Blogs and the internet at large for no good reason. A narrative about me has already been established by 'Lousy Canuck' and people are defending the indefensible - sending DMCA requests which lead to censorship and create a chilling effect. This sort of behavior, I would think, should not taking place in the skeptic community.

Again, the address wasn't posted with malicious intent. It's public information and was posted because people were alleging that I has malicious intent in filing the counter-DMCA request. Although I strongly disagree with 'Surly Amy,' I mean no ill-will on her personal life or the personal life of whomever she may live with. It would have been nice for people to ask questions surrounding the posting of the address rather than jumping to conclusions of malicious intent.

Response to 'Surly Amy' and 'Lousy Canuck'


Blogger Jason Thibeault, writing for the blog 'Lousy Canuck,' has recently authored a post titled “The campaign against Amy Davis Roth” in which he authors a very passionate defense of 'Surly Amy' who has -- on his account -- been “under concerted attack.” His post is largely an emotional appeal which fails because he misrepresents many things and seems to consider everyone who merely disagrees with 'Surly Amy' to be a nasty bully. Within the post, he heaps abuse at me, distorts many things, and references the DMCA (Digital Millenium Copyright Act) complaint I received which may have been from 'Surly Amy.' I go unnamed, but am obviously referred to as 'Entity.'

Here's my response - as long as it needs to be without going overboard:

Jason begins his post discussing how much he likes 'Surly Amy.' He notes that he had a good experience with her and recently his “already favorable impression of Amy was redoubled when [he] has found out that she'd nearly singlehandledly sent dozens of women to TAMover the years, organizing and running fundraisers and committing resources from her Surlys to that end.” So be it. I appreciate that she has launched fundraising efforts to send women to TAM and am happy that an associate of mine whom I also met in-person and have a favorable impression of was part of that group. 'Surly Amy' has done great things...that is not a matter I am contesting. ...but it's not all happy trails as Jason makes it out to be.

In Jason's post, I am unfairly lumped in with a group of people whom he describes as engaging in a “concerted attack” against 'Surly Amy.' Among these people and this “concerted attack,” he notes people upset about the Skepchick network and mentions D.J. Grothe - the president of the James Randi Educational Foundation.

It was because of what I saw as, contrary to what Jason might believe, the “concerted attack” against D.J. Grothe, the James Randi Educational Foundation, and The Amazing Meeting which had led me to speak up [back in the beginning of June] and, if you will, 'get involved in the drama' (although I would have really liked to – and would like to – exclusively focus on church/state activism, debates, speaking, etc...). Jason was a person who had usedthe word 'douchebag' in reference to D.J. Grothe. Additionally, many persons from the Skepchick network and Freethought Blogs (Jason included) had some really nasty things to say about the JREF, D.J., and The Amazing Meeting. [...but that's a story for another day. Gee, I wonder why people would be upset the Skepchick network and Freethought Blogs?]

Jason also mentions Dr. Harriet Hall, who had worn a t-shirt -- presumably in response to all of the “concerted attacks” from Skepchick (mainly from Rebecca Watson) and the Freethought Blogs network concerning The JREF, The Amazing Meeting, and the James Randi Educational Foundation – which had said Hall was “not a skepchick” and that she feels “safe and welcome at TAM” (oh, the horror!). Some persons also wore 'fake jewelry' (I'll get to that later) and sung a satirical song about how Skephicks, on Jason's account, have sticks up their asses. Jason also mentions more. 'Surly Amy,' after all of this, left the conference a day early after crying. Jason then mentions a letter from Paula Kirby with the language of 'feminazi' and 'femistasi,' forum trolling, Twitter trolling, and criticism from Thunderf00t.

While I might not have worn 'fake jewelry,' a t-shirt which Amy didn't like, or sung a song about Skepchicks having sticks up their asses, used the word 'feminazi,' it is no surprise that there was such a reaction. When particular bloggers on Skepchick and Freethought Blogs dedicate so much time, so much effort, and so many posts talking about how horrible D.J. Grothe, The Amazing Meeting, and the JREF is [and that's just the tip of the grievances...nevermind the attacks on Chris Stedman, Penn Jilette, Richard Dawkins, Staks Rosch and so many more...], a response in this manner seems plausible.

'Surly Amy' has befriended and associated herself with with people like myself (and I am not alone in this by any means) see nastiness, vitriol, and a complete waste of time that could have been handled much better. The message is quite clear. People don't like 'Surly Amy.' People don't like particular writers on Freethought Blogs. People don't like particular writers on the Skepchick network.


(Some commenters on Freethought Blogs aren't too charitable...)

Some of what 'Surly Amy' has faced may be considered outright bullying (and it's something I certainly didn't engage in), but nonetheless Jason lumps me into the group. Jason – and many others -- seem to unjustly lump all critics into one group as a bunch of nasty misogynist sexist privileged douchebag gender-traitor/dudebro thugs while failing to realize -- as many fundamentalist theists I have encountered – that many who disagreearen't disrespectful and honest civil criticism can be had.

So, what have I said about Amy? I authored two posts (before the DMCA complaint I received which I will get to later in this post) concerning 'Surly Amy' rebuking oneskeptical blogger Sharon Hill for following a parody account onTwitter saying, to Hill, “you should be embarrassed” (which curiously appeared on the 'fake jewelry' 'Surly Amy' spoke of. I had a lengthy Twitter discussion with 'Surly Amy' about how people have different tastes in humor and how it is inappropriate to place demands on people for a matter of subjective differences. 


Within my conversation and within the blog post that followed, I offered criticism free of name-calling, personal attacks, abuse, etc. - as this is something I aspire to steer clear of in my work for very good reasons. I even recently gave a speech about the importance of civility in discussion and hosted a podcast episode where this was discussed (to just name two things). You can look for yourself at the blog post about 'Surly Amy' and see that.

My second post -- "Surly Amy: Conference should ban 'fake jewelry'" concerned criticism of what 'Surly Amy' said on a podcast with host Amanda Marcotte. 'Surly Amy' said, and I quote,

“There was this group of, again, very vocal angry troll-like people that did some really awful things to me in real life - that sort of thing that you usually only see online I was actually face to face with. I had people wearing t-shirts saying that they were not a skepchick, people making fake jewelry that I make that said things on it like 'you should be embarrassed.' There's this really crazy undercurrent of othering that I had never experienced before and it was really upsetting and I ended up leaving the event a day early.” 
“We're not asking for anything crazy - just basic rules so that we can say the sort of thing like making fake jewelry and intentionally offending people is not okay nor is grabbing someone's ass. That's it, that's all we're asking for.”

I offered criticism of these ideas 'Surly Amy' had while arguing that it's unreasonable for conference organizers to ban 'fake jewelry' and t-shirts on the grounds of someone merely claiming offense. If 'Surly Amy's' ideas would come to fruition, censorship would be the result – and that's something the atheist/skeptic community should be against. I wrote that because 'Surly Amy' held this attitude, she should be disqualified from the ongoing conversation concerning anti-harassment polices at conferences. I wrote,
If 'Surly Amy' and others had their way -- according to what 'Surly Amy' said in this podcast and logical conclusions which seem to follow -- conferences would ban others' freedom of expression and speech on grounds of a person claiming offense. I hope this day never comes, but it might just be on its way if people continue to consider 'Surly Amy' as a valid participant in the discussion concerning anti-harassment policies at conferences. Her wanting to restrict which jewelry people wear at conferences, though, should hopefully disqualify her from this discussion. Is this the sort of feminism that is worth wanting? 'Surly Amy,' after all, is not some 'rogue voice' or 'extremist' who has little clout; she is a well-respected and listened to voice within in the feminist atheist community. 
Are you, reader, in agreement with 'Surly Amy?' 
Should jewelry which leads people to claim offense be banned from conferences?
Despite this very fair post which offered criticism of ideas in a very civil fashion – much unlike other examples Jason refers to such as outright making fun of 'Surly Amy' -- Jason has put me in a group of a concerted campaign against 'Surly Amy.'

Enter, then, the recent DMCA complaint which I received directed my blog post offering criticism of 'Surly Amy' comments concerning how conference organizers should ban 'fake jewelry.' Included in the post, with a caption noting the image was a Surly-Ramic, was an image of Surly Amy's “This is what a feminist looks like” jewelry. I used this because this provided a criticism of Surly Amy's ideas and was relevant to the post considering that 'Surly Amy' identifies as a feminist. As is usually the case, I provide images with my blog posts that are relevant to the post in question. I have never had any legal problems because of this. All sorts of people do this under fair use.

Once, though, I used a picture of me from a local newspaper and was asked, by e-mail, by the photographer, to caption the picture indicating its source. I did that with no problem and there were no further issues. Everyone was happy. This, though, was not the case with 'Surly Amy' or whomever filed this DMCA complaint; I received no request to take down the picture, but instead, before anything else, received an e-mail containing a legal complaint which forced the image offline. Apparently, though, 'Surly Amy' asked blogger thunderf00t to remove an image she had the copyright of and he complied.

Returning to Jason's post, Jason refers to me as a troll (this is no new news because he, along with his blogger compatriot PZ Myers, called me a “vacuous shitbag troll”) and writes, referring to 'Surly Amy,' “Then the trolls get the bright idea to wreck her art at the same time as going after her personally.” 

This is quite an odd assertion considering that my post did nothing more than criticize the ideas, in quite a fair and civil manner, 'Surly Amy' presented. The post had nothing to do with her business or, as Jason says, “wrecking her art.” I did not say something like, “People should boycott Surly-Ramics because she is a no-good x, y, and z who is a very bad artist.” Nothing of the sort was said. I offered criticism of ideas just like Jason (and many others did) in reference to D.J. Grothe.

Jason, continuing, writes, without using my name and heaping abuse at me,
Then a certain disingenuous and argumentationally-vacuous entity in our community, who claims both to be a leader and to represent the moral high ground of attacking people’s arguments instead of their person, posts a copyrighted image of Amy’s in order to try to cut her down. This entity — henceforth known as Entity (who will go unlinked, so I’m not accused of trying to ruin their reputation in a bullying fashion by pointing out their trollish actions!) — wrote the post to say that Amy is divisive and damaging to the community because she wants conferences to ban the parody jewellery, rather than what she actually suggested, that harassment policies would provide frameworks for complaining about being targeted for harassment like she had been. The entire post was a straw dummy, as is Entity’s modus operandi, but the post stood unopposed, unmentioned and unloved, until Blogger’s automatic DMCA takedown process reverted the post to draft status until the blogger in question could remove the offending image.
It's quite odd that Jason says that I claim to be a leader since I actually am a leader of a local secular community group and have – and continue to have – high regard within secular organizations,groups, etc. perhaps as a direct result of my church/state activism (which was curiously enough lauded by many on the Freethought Blogs network including most notably PZ Myers and 'Blag Hag' concerning the rejected "Atheists." bus ads), writing, speaking, podcasting, etc. I even was recently invited tospeak at the Secular Student Alliance's 2012 Leadership Conference and received a thank-you card following that. Nevermind any of that, though, continue on with the personal attacks...


(Freethought Blogs blogger Greta Christina mentions rejected "Atheists." bus ad 

around the 4:44 mark in this Reason Rally clip.)

Jason considers my post to be a 'strawdummy' as is allegedly my modus operandi (that's news to me - I would like to see other examples of me doing this!) Jason says that 'Surly Amy' really said “that harassment policies should provide frameworks for complaining about harassment like she had been.”  It is, though, quite clear that 'Surly Amy' said she and others are “not asking for anything crazy – just basic rules so that we can say the sort of thing like making fake jewelry and intentionally offending people is not okay not is grabbing someone's ass. That's it, that's all we're asking for.” 

I don't see how much clearer it can get than that.

Here's the thing – filing a DMCA request against someone, especially without asking said person to remove the image in question which is supposedly the problem – is bullying behavior which should be, regardless of the claimant or the person being DMCA'd, outright condemned by the atheist/skeptic community. It seems to be nothing more than censorship and an admission that one simply can't handle the criticism (odd, being that the recipient is a public figure who, by being on the internet and making convtroversial statements, should expect criticism and be able to handle it). Unlike many others Jason mentioned as part of an alleged “concerted attack,” I was extremely charitable and authored a post free from personal attacks. It is such a shame that nowhere in Jason's post did he condemn this DMCA bullying.

Jason continues,
So people now have a rhetorical club to beat Amy with. Despite there being no evidence that Amy herself posted the DMCA takedown notice, it’s very probably her because she’s the copyright owner. But the action recommended in the takedown notice was to remove the offending content and the rest could be republished. Did Entity do that? Of course not. Instead, Entity filed a DMCA counter-claim...
This alleged “rhetorical club to beat Amy with” was something handed down by 'Surly Amy' and given to me and others if it really is the case that she filed the DMCA. (...and what a weapon it is!) The DMCA is unacceptable and should be something that leads people, if it is indeed 'Surly Amy' who filed the DMCA, to arrive at a conclusion with which they lose respect for 'Surly Amy' even if she makes nice jewelry and sends people to conventions as per fundraisers. After all, many were willing to do this (and perhaps have) because of Richard Dawkins' “dear Muslima” comments. (although Rebecca Watson totally didn't call for a boycott!) /sarcasm

'Surly Amy,' though, has suspiciously – as far as I know – remained quiet on this DMCA issue. She's blocked people on Twitter who have asked her about it. She's told me to leave her alone and has totally distanced herself from this. She hasn't confirmed or denied whether she filed the DMCA. One would think that if she didn't file the DMCA, she would want to absolve herself from guilt. At least that is what I would think rational people would do...but perhaps that is 'my privilege speaking.'

Jason claims I did not take down the image for whatever reason (I took the image down almost within seconds of seeing the takedown notice) and, from the looks of his post, that I filed a DMCA counter-claim to keep the image up. This accounting is false.

I pondered whether or not I would file the counter-claim (after taking down the image) and decided to do so after some advice from friends with what might be my foolhardy sense of courage, pride, integrity, and honor. I absolutely refuse to be bullied by people using legal measures to shut me down and will not tolerate it. I didn't tolerate it back in 2011 when I received threats from a chiropractor's fiancee' and will not now. I don't intend to take 'Surly Amy' to court (what a waste of money and time that would be which should not be something the atheist/skeptic community engages in!) like Jason seems to allude to.

I have, following this DMCA claim, adopted a 'fake jewelry' avatar created by Reap Paden on my posts (reading “Don't censor me Amy") and on my online profiles to show that I will not stand for this sort of bullying. Filing a DMCA which leads to takedown of criticism is repugnant behavior. Again, I received no e-mail from 'Surly Amy' asking me to take the image down or better attribute it (although it seems like it was fair use, which I argued in my DMCA counter-claim).


While there are some people indeed bullying 'Surly Amy,' I am not one of them. It seems though, as an odd turn of events, that 'Surly Amy' [if she indeed filed the DMCA] is the real bully here. Against possibly everything 'the movement' which prides itself on free speech and honest criticism stands for (note: not 'Surly Amy's ideas of feminism which, according to Amanda Marcotte, are “consistent” with atheism along withpro-choice positions), 'Surly Amy' – instead of sending me an e-mail asking for the image to be removed [if it is the case that she filed the DMCA].

For that, and just for that (regardless of Jason's long emotional appeal post), the atheist/skeptic community should distance themselves from 'Surly Amy.' This is no bullying, “concerted attack,” or 'an attack on her art.' This is an appropriate response. ...and this is the same response many should have and have had concerning DMCA complaints targeting people criticial of creationist claims.

People are sick of all the nonsense stemming from the Skepchick and Freethought Blogs networks (although, admittedly, there are still some good people there). ...and it's not only me. It's also Paula Kirby, Sam Harris, Russell Blackford, D.J. Grothe, Jeremy Stangroom, Richard Dawkins, Mallorie Nasrallah, John Loftus, Thunderfoot, and so so so many more (including all of those who are silent!). Of the 'so so so many more,' people have contacted me in confidence showing their support and rebuking Freethought Blogs bloggers and Skepchick writers but are afraid to go public because of the consequences which may follow.


(Ridicule from PZ Myers directed at me)

While the previously mentioned names don't necessarily agree with me on everything (or have the same feelings about everything concerning Freethought Blogs and Skepchick), it is likely that they are sick of the constant needless drama and in-fighting which could be avoided and/or handled in a more civil manner. We aren't sexist misogynist dudebros/gender-traitors for this. Hell, we can even be labeled as feminists although we have a different take on feminism when compared to 'Surly Amy' and company.


(More hate from PZ Myers directed at me)

Jason ended his post with an appeal for people who are “sick of the nonsense” to “support someone who's supported out community even while the cockroaches targeted her.” In the same light, feel free, if you are “sick of the nonsense” to support me. Perhaps this is less shameless than Jason's asking people to donate money to 'Surly Amy?' You be the judge of that...

After all, I would wager that I do much more (or at least a considerable comparable amount) for the community than certain bloggers...and don't work to divide this movement by levying constant personal attacks at people, heaping abuse at those whom I disagree, or filing legal complaints to take down posts I might happen to not like. I write for almost no money, incur expenses when travelling to events which I have been invited to speak at, and volunteer my services to my local freethought group while producing the podcast for no money. A donation would be much appreciated.

You can also purchase from the NEPA Freethought Society store.

Thank you.

- Justin “vacuous shitbag troll" "Fucking” Vacula



Update: Three more DMCAs have been filed against people using Surly-Ramics images in their posts. Is this really about images or is it something else? I'm inclined to believe the latter. More bullying. Look, even if you don't like the criticism -- whether it be fair or not -- resorting to DMCA tactics is unacceptable. Youtuber and blogger 'GirlWritesWhat' has also received DMCAs.

DMCA Counter-Complaint and more

Image provided by Reap Paden. Don't DMCA me!
Following the DMCA complaint I received which resulted in a removal of my post titled "Surly Amy: Conferences should ban 'fake jewelry'" (also now available on Scribd and Youtube) I have filed a counter-complaint arguing that my usage of a Surly-Ramics image was fair-use. The post itself, related to the image in question "This is what a feminist looks like" --  which was captioned noting where the image was from -- was criticism of feminist 'Surly Amy' and her ideas concerning conference policies, feminism, and more.

Whether you agree with the content of my work, hate me, love me, want to give me an Atheist Air Hug, or are indifferent, it should be quite clear that filing DMCA complaints which removes content that offers criticism is unacceptable. This seems to be nothing more than censorship.

If the image in question were the real problem, I would have expected to receive an e-mail kindly asking for me to remove the image. Instead, a legal complaint led to the removal of the post in question. This is not the behavior I would expect from skeptics who value free-speech.

If 'Surly Amy' is so confident of the strength of her arguments (that conferences should ban 'fake jewelry' and saying that intentionally offending people is not okay) and believes that her behaviors (namely rebuking people on Twitter for following parody accounts and crying because of, in part, a t-shirt) are justified there should be no problem with my offering criticism which is free of name-calling, personal attacks, slurs, etc. I don't see people like William Lane Craig filing DMCA claims as a response to my content.

It is still unclear whether 'Surly Amy' filed the DCMA complaint. It is possible that someone masquerading as 'Surly Amy' filed the complaint. 'Surly Amy,' though, has neither confirmed or denied whether she filed the DMCA complaint. Her fellow writers on the Skepchick network are also quiet about the incident. Why no response, 'Surly Amy?'

Back in 2011, I received legal threats for offering criticism of a local chiropractor. At the time, atheist blogger PZ Myers was very supportive and drew attention to the situation by authoring a post on his blog. Various other atheists and skeptics were similarly on my side with the belief that using legal action which results in or could result in a silencing of people offering criticism is unacceptable. I would expect the same support in regards to this DMCA complaint.

Thankfully, fellow atheists/skeptics have weighed in or otherwise have shown support concerning this issue:
Atheist Revolution
Mike The Infidel
Scented Nectar
Reap Paden
The Mad Skeptic
Katie Graham
SpinozasPsyche
AVoiceForMen - via GirlWritesWhat
Tea Fueled Madness

Hopefully I can add you to the list. It's time for people in the atheist/skeptic community -- much like 'Surly Amy's' initiative for people to rebuke hate directed toward women -- to say that using legal action which results in censorship is unacceptable.

I'm not going to be bullied by people who file DMCA complaints which results in censorship and may result in my entire blog being taken offline. I have responded, as Google afforded me to, arguing that my use of the Surly-Ramics image in my post was fair use. Again, no matter what you think of me or 'Surly Amy,' filing DMCA complaints which result in censorship is unacceptable. It's ridiculous that this post even has to exist within a community which is -- last time I checked -- opposed to censorship of dissent.

The confirmation e-mail of my DMCA counter-claim is below:

DMCA received on Surly Amy post

'Fake Jewelry' image provided by Reap Paden
Update: I have filed a DMCA counter-complaining arguing my usage of the Surly-Ramics necklace was fair use. Read about that here.

On August 8. 2012, I authored a blog post titled "Surly Amy: Conferences should ban 'fake jewelry'" (now also available here on Youtube and Scribd in the event of another DMCA claim) which contained a picture of a 'Surly-Ramics' necklace [now taken down] which said "This is what a feminist looks like." Apparently, the picture of this necklace led someone, perhaps 'Surly Amy' herself, to file a Digital Millenium Copyright Act claim against me which resulted in the post being reverted to draft status and removed - although I placed the post up once again.

Here is an e-mail I received informing me of the DMCA claim:






This is very interesting considering that the post contained criticism of 'Surly Amy' who I charged with
wanting to censor free speech and free expression. In a podcast episode with Amanda Macrotte, 'Surly Amy' said,
There was this group of, again, very vocal angry troll-like people that did some really awful things to me in real life - that sort of thing that you usually only see online I was actually face to face with. I had people wearing t-shirts saying that they were not a skepchick, people making fake jewelry that I make that said things on it like 'you should be embarrassed.' There's this really crazy undercurrent of othering that I had never experienced before and it was really upsetting and I ended up leaving the event a day early. 
We're not asking for anything crazy - just basic rules so that we can say the sort of thing like making fake jewelry and intentionally offending people is not okay nor is grabbing someone's ass. That's it, that's all we're asking for.
'Surly Amy,' as one can reasonably infer, wants to ban particular jewelry and t-shirts from conferences -- thus censoring free speech -- because she claims offense. Now, as it seems, blog posts are also problematic and should be censored.

Within the post, I offered some criticism of 'Surly Amy' as follows:
If 'Surly Amy' and others had their way -- according to what 'Surly Amy' said in this podcast and logical conclusions which seem to follow -- conferences would ban others' freedom of expression and speech on grounds of a person claiming offense. I hope this day never comes, but it might just be on its way if people continue to consider 'Surly Amy' as a valid participant in the discussion concerning anti-harassment policies at conferences. Her wanting to restrict which jewelry people wear at conferences, though, should hopefully disqualify her from this discussion. Is this the sort of feminism that is worth wanting? 'Surly Amy,' after all, is not some 'rogue voice' or 'extremist' who has little clout; she is a well-respected and listened to voice within in the feminist atheist community.
I don't know if 'Surly Amy' filed the DMCA complaint against me or not, but someone did. Might this person be a fan of 'Surly Amy' or otherwise be someone who doesn't like me? Silencing, it seems, rather than responding, is the weapon of choice for some. I wonder...why instead, if the picture were really the issue, the DMCA claimant send me a communication asking for the removal of the image when they know that a removal of the blog post would also happen. Perhaps that was the intention?

This, though, isn't just a small problem. Aside from exposing the cowardice of people DMCAing me likely because I offered criticism of 'Surly Amy' (this was the removed post), my blog may be taken offline and deleted because of multiple DMCA requests which may be upcoming. The claimant has resorted to unnecessary legal action in what seems to be an attempt to silence me.

This wouldn't be the first time, either, that someone is appearing to use legal threats to remove my blog from the internet. Last year, I received legal threats from a chiropractor's fiancee' following my criticism. I did not expect the same behavior -- and this is even worse -- from skeptics who, I though, are supposed to be charitable and rational...and not in the business of attempting to remove websites or posts on websites they dislike when other means can be had to remove images they may own (if that is even the real issue).

Update:
Another person critical of feminist bloggers recently received a DMCA complaint. Might we have been targeted by the same person or persons? Is this just a coincidence?

3 more, too, were served here.

Ophelia Benson's continuing complaining

Ophelia Benson - Wikipedia
On July 2 of 2012, I hosted -- along with Karla Porter -- a discussion titled "Women and the secular community" [listen here] and invited all of my Facebook friends (including, at the time, Ophelia Benson). The event was described as follows (from the Facebook event):

The NEPA Freethought Society Podcast will be having a very special Livestream episode (streaming at www.nepafreethought.org/livestream) featuring Karla Porter and Justin Vacula concerning an ongoing discussion in the secular community -- more specifically in the blogosphere -- regarding women in the secular community this Monday at 8PM EST. 
Topics to be discussed are sexism, harassment at conferences, anti-harassment conference policies, harassment, tone, specific posts and comments by identified feminist bloggers including "Sisterhood of the Oppressed," a recent GoogleDoc by Paula Kirby (http://bit.ly/Od1bqB), "On Harassment and Policies: An Open Letter to Skeptic and Freethought Leaders" by Todd Stiefel (http://bit.ly/LFr5Vg), "Closing the File" by Ophelia Benson (http://bit.ly/M1ff4c), "Why I Won't be at TAM this year" by Rebecca Watson, (http://skepchick.org/2012/06/why-i-wont-be-at-tam-this-year/) and much more
During the discussion, Karla and I discussed -- as promised -- e-mails blogger Ophelia Benson received which ultimately lead to her neglecting to speak at and attend The Amazing Meeting. Ophelia didn't like the treatment she received on the podcast and posted her dissatisfaction on my Facebook profile and elsewhere. Here are some of those comments:

(her initial comments from my Facebook page)



Following that, she then complained about the podcast once again on her blog (which she banned me from commenting on following what I thought was a very reasonable proposal):



...she then followed up on Twitter:





...and there's also this:


...and now she's doing it once more:



I don't really understand this. Ophelia Benson doesn't want to appear as a guest on my podcast which apparently bothered her so much that she keeps mentioning it, but she continues to talk about it. I have given her an opportunity (one which still stands) to rectify whatever harm or misrepresentation she believes she's incurred and she wants nothing to do with it. She's also banned me from her Twitter and blog. Apparently, she doesn't want to have a conversation, but she keeps mentioning the treatment she received on the podcast while hurling insults at me. What's the point?

When I disagree with people so much that I post about what they say, I welcome a dialogue with them. I don't hurl character attacks, I don't call them 'disgraceful,' 'unethical,' 'not too careful with the truth,' 'a hack pursuing a vendetta,' a 'dishonest hack,' an 'asshole' or claim that their posts are 'calculated insults.' Apparently, Ophelia isn't interested in dialogue, but rather is only interested in attacking people with whom she disagrees.

Ophelia, while you're at it, why don't you just dedicate an entire post to how much you disliked the podcast and hop on the train of your fellow blog writers who delight in calling me a 'vacuous shitbag troll?' Remember, though, hate directed at women is uncalled for...but everyone else is fair game.



Atheism has nothing to do with feminism or pro-choice positions


Amanda Marcotte, host of the RH Reality Check podcast, recently authored a post titled "Atheism is Consistent with Feminism and Pro-Choice Positions." In this post, I'll examine various reasons Amanda Marcotte gives for this assertion and show why I believe she's deeply mistaken.

(This post won't address much of the other content in Marcotte's post, namely that there is a "particularly nasty and virulent form of sexism in the community of activist atheists and claims concerning 'Surly Amy' and the alleged 'ugliness' she faced at The Amazing Meeting. If you're interested in that, read here.)

Before commenting on the specific reasons Marcotte provides, it should be first important to note what atheism is. Atheism, as it's commonly understood, and how I use the term, is lack of belief in any gods. The lack of belief in any gods does not entail any other facts about a person. Atheism -- although there may be a large percentage of atheists at least in America who share some unrelated common ideals -- is no indication of political views, positions on social issues, guarantee of intelligence, educational background, ideas concerning feminism, or socioeconomic status.

To note that atheism is consistent with something -- such as 'feminism and pro-choice positions -- seems to be an empty statement. How is the fact that one lacks belief in any gods 'consistent' with one's views on abortion and women/gender equality? It's quite obvious that many atheists who oppose all forms of abortions and do not hold the same ideas about feminism as Marcotte exist (regardless of the strength of the arguments). What about feminists who are in opposition to abortion? Are these people also being 'inconsistent?'

What, then, does Marcotte supply to warrant her assertion that atheism is consistent with feminism and pro-choice positions? She writes,
For me, being an outspoken atheist has always been firmly intertwined with my feminism, and in fact, really it's the result of my feminism. I never really believed in a god of any sort, but the notion that atheism is important and should be talked about openly is one I only really developed because it serves the larger goal of creating a world that has true gender equality" 
While it's possible that a position on one issue (namely that organized religion, as it seems Marcotte believes, is harmful to women) may lead one to be outspoken on another issue, this in no way means that Marcotte's lack of belief in any gods is 'consistent' with her feminist positions. While being open about atheism may be serve the larger goal of creating a world that has true gender equality, this by no means supports the assertion that atheism is consistent with pro-choice positions or feminism.

Continuing, she writes,
Feminism and atheism are intertwined for me both on a philosophical and pragmatic level. Philosophically, I’ve always thought that making the question “are women people” a matter of theological debate is silly. One side quotes one Bible verse and another quotes one back, and really, the people who believe women are vessels aren’t wrong to think the Bible has their back. From the very first book of the Bible, women are cast as creatures that exist to serve men and not as full human beings in their own right. Various other religious traditions have the same problem of casting men as people and women as appendages. That runs so contrary to what seems obvious to me, that women are people just as much as men.
It's quite possible to get 'nowhere' in a discussion which involves quoting Bible verses although, as Marcotte may not know, there are feminist theologians and the matter of 'are woman people' is likely decided for reasons other than appeals to religion, but that's another story. While the Bible has, in many points, a grim view of women, an evaluation of 'the Bible got it wrong, this doesn't mean that atheism is 'consistent' with feminism and pro-choice positions.

Marcotte then moves on to discuss atheist thinkers who she identifies as feminists:
It was atheist thinkers who I first encountered who had an explanation for gender that comported better with the real world evidence. Simone de Beauvoir, author of the seminal text “The Second Sex”, laid out a rationale for feminism that was firmly rooted in her atheist existentialist philosophy. To wildly oversimplify her extremely long argument: There is no God. Therefore, there is no higher authority telling us what we are here “for”. Therefore we have the right to define our own purpose for ourselves. There is no rational reason that this right should only be extended to men, because again, there’s no higher power assigning one gender the role of leaders and the other of servants. Thus, women are equal to men, and as a matter of human decency, should have the same right to self-determination. Elegant, persuasive, and above all other things, logical and evidence-based. Atheism, by all rights, should lead to feminism, I thought. It’s just what’s rational.
Marcotte's discussion about purpose is a philosophical one and not something that is a result of lack of belief in any gods. While some religious believers may believe that women and men have different roles in life or purposes, do it follow that a rejection of this should lead to feminism? One can, even without a god belief, hold on to the idea -- similar to what some religious believers may hold -- that women do not have the same right to self-determination as men. Various non-theological reasons, I am sure Marcotte is aware of, which consigned women to 'traditional roles' need no appeal to gods to be persisted such as 'women should be homemakers,' 'the main responsibility of women is to bear children and care for them,' and 'women should please their husbands.' While religion may have had a role to play in this, it seems foolish to suggest that a rejection of religious belief should, as Marcotte says, "lead to feminism" (or a particular position concerning the meaning of life or purpose).

It's also important to note, as I previously alluded to, that not all those who happen to lack a belief in any gods are very rational people. Atheism is not arrived at by every person as a result of careful reflection, responding well to arguments from religious believers, and a good understanding of arguments against gods. Many atheists, as Marcotte and many who are active in the online community should know, aren't very rational.

She continues,
Atheism in service of feminism drew me in for pragmatic reasons, too. The biggest battle over women’s rights in this country revolves around reproductive rights, which makes it a battle over faith, since there is no evidence-based, rational argument for restricting a woman’s right to choose if and when she gives birth.
While this may be the case (and I am pro-choice myself), there are plenty of arguments against abortion. Although the arguments may fail, they exist. Although religious appeals may contribute to anti-abortion positions, it's not simply a religious/faith-based issue.
Nor is there really an argument outside of a faith-based one to believe that a brainless embryo is the equivalent to a baby; to ignore the scientific reality that women create other people in our bodies by gestating them in favor of believing men create other people by ejaculating means a belief that the act of conception is supernatural, that a Christian idea of the “soul” is somehow injected into an egg along with a sperm.
Not all arguments against abortion stipulate that a 'brainless embryo is equivalent to a baby.' Some anti-abortion arguments are concerned not with whether an embryo is equivalent to a baby, but rather are concerned with potentiality or the 'future like ours' - again, having nothing to do with religious appeals.
Even anti-choicers grasp this; they “believe” that “life begins at conception.” It’s a belief. It has no relationship with the facts. And that belief is fundamentally religious in nature. That’s why it’s important to understand that attempts to ban abortion or get fertilized eggs legally defined as “persons” are attempts to violate the First Amendment and use the state to impose a certain kind of religious dogma.
I'm confused here by Marcotte putting quotes around the word belief. A belief, as I understand it, is a proposition that one holds to be corresponding with reality. Stating that something is a belief that has no relationship with the facts means that something is, then, a false belief. Anyway, ideas that life begins at conception, again, aren't all religiously-based. The matter of life, anyway, is a philosophical (not a scientific) issue although science may inform our belief of when life starts or what life is. While people who attempt to define eggs as persons or otherwise try to ban abortion might be operating under religious dogma, it's not the case that all of these attempts are religious in nature.

Marcotte continues,

For this reason, it seemed to me that supporting the growing atheist movement would benefit reproductive rights in the long run.
Sure, this might be the case because many atheists happen to be sympathetic to Marcotte's causes of reproductive freedom and pro-choice positions (myself included), but not simply because they lack belief in any gods.
Anti-choicers insist that the debate over choice is a theological one over when “life,” i.e. ensoulment begins. If the public at large understood that a substantial percentage of Americans don’t believe in souls at all, then it would be much easier to see why the theological question of when “life” begins has no place in the law at all.


Not all persons, again, opposed to abortion, are crafting a theological debate. Even if persons didn't believe in souls, there would still be opposition to abortion. While that opposition might go down, this doesn't mean that atheism is consistent with pro-choice positions. The matter of what life, to restate, is is not merely a theological question (and not necessarily based on the soul).

Her last paragraph notes,
Of course, all these arguments depended on an atheist movement comprised of people who saw the way that religion and patriarchy are intertwined, and saw that refusing to believe in God, if followed to its logical conclusion, means abandoning the belief that women exist to serve men. In my interactions with the atheist movement, I would say most activist atheists do see these things and have logically come around to feminism because of it. But [...] a not-insubstantial percentage of atheist men have convinced themselves they can both not believe in a god and somehow still conclude that women were put (by who?) here on Earth for the purpose of pleasing and catering to men
I fail to see how refusing to believe in God leads to 'the logical conclusion' of abandoning the belief that women exist to serve men. I would like to see a deductive argument for this. Anyway, Marcotte's framing of issues, as we have already seen with her ideas concerning opposition to abortion, is very oversimplified. There is a vast array of positions falling under the umbrella of feminism and much disagreement amongst persons who consider themselves to be feminists. Is there really a 'not-insubstantial percentage' of people, as Marcotte asserts, who are activist atheists who believe that 'women were put here on Earth for the purpose of pleasing and catering to men?'

There are certainly atheist activists who object to some ideas that atheist bloggers such as PZ Myers, Rebecca Watson, 'Surly Amy,' Stephanie Zvan, and Ophelia Benson (and even Marcotte) hold... but I find it very hard to believe that these same people believe that women were put on Earth to please and cater to men. How does Marcotte arrive at this conclusion?

Amanda Marcotte doesn't seem to effectively argue that atheism is consistent with feminism and pro-choice positions. She's 'dead at the gate' considering that atheism is merely an indicator of one issue -- whether a person believes in any gods -- and does not guarantee anything else about a person - especially whether the person is or should be pro-choice or in agreement with Amanda Marcotte's take on feminism. Marcotte grossly oversimplifies issues of abortion and seems to have some philosophical misunderstandings while seemingly believing that a rejection of belief in God, as she writes, "if followed to its logical conclusion" leads to beliefs about women. Atheism has nothing to do with feminism or pro-choice positions - and it can't considering that atheism is a position on one issue and secular opposition to pro-choice positions and ideas of Marcotte's concerning feminism exist.

A philosophy lesson for Stephanie Zvan, PZ Myers, and everyone else

                                                 
Blogger Stephanie Zvan recently published a blog post containing a great deal of philosophical confusion following blogger PZ Myers' philosophical confusion. In this post -- a response to Myers and Zvan's post -- I discuss what an argument is and talk about thought experiments with hope to dispel all of this confusion.
I previously commented on atheist blogger and biologist PZ Myers' recent assertion -- in a post titled "The only abortion argument that counts" -- that abortion reduces to "a simple question."

Myers wrote,
We can make all the philosophical and scientific arguments that anyone might want, but ultimately what it all reduces to is a simple question: do women have autonomous control of their bodies or not? Even if I thought embryos were conscious, aware beings writing poetry in the womb (I don’t, and they’re not), I’d have to bow out of any say in the decision the woman bearing responsibility has to make.
I argued that the issue of abortion is not as simple as PZ makes it out to be and, contrary to what he wrote, that philosophical arguments actually do matter. I noted objections to pro-choice stances and reasons why persons would not think abortion reduces to a simple question -- regardless of whether the objections or reasons are persuasive -- and noted that PZ's assertion itself seems to be a philosophical claim.

Following my commentary, philosopher Massimo Pigliucci -- in a post titled "Okay, let's talk about abortion" -- offered criticism of Myers' post in which he discussed Judith Jarvis Thomson's "A Defense of Abortion" paper which contains various thought experiments. Pigliucci further discussed responses to Thomson's paper showing that the issue of abortion is not a simple one.

Massimo wrote,
...one does need arguments and/or evidence for any rational position, no matter how "obvious" such position may seem at first glance. Otherwise, one takes himself de facto out of the community of reason. In this instance, a bit more philosophical reading would have done PZ a world of good. Moreover, the debate is far from simple and obvious, as should by the number of thoughtful papers written in response or support of [Judith Jarvis] Thomson's ideas. Most of these papers have been written by professional moral philosophers, not fundamentalist cranks. And many of the objections come from authors who are also pro-choice... 
Stephanie Zvan -- blogger for the Freethought Blogs network writing for the blog 'Almost Diamonds' -- recently authored a post titled "Just What Philosophers Do?" which draws on Myers' comments about abortion. In her post, she used the phrases "PZ's argument," the "counter-factuals [which] serve different purposes in PZ's argument," and "people he is arguing with."

PZ, though, didn't provide any arguments. In fact, he wrote the following: "We can make all the philosophical and scientific arguments that anyone might want, but ultimately what it all reduces to is a simple question..." What arguments of PZ, then, is Zvan referring to throughout her blog post?

When philosophers speak of arguments, premises and conclusions are of concern. At a very basic level, something is being argued for (the conclusion) and is supported by statements (premises) which should lead to the conclusion.

Consider the following:
(1) Jake is a King's College student if he is on the King's College roster.
(2) Jake is on the King's College roster.
(3) Jake is a King's College student.

In the above structure, (1) and (2) are premises [reasons given to establish a conclusion] and (3) is the conclusion [something that is being argued for].

Not all arguments, though are as clear as the above structure because some hidden premises and conclusions may exist. Consider the following: "An all-loving god would not create a universe with natural disasters, so an all-loving god does not exist." Here, the premises of the argument are not explicit, but with some investigation and understanding, an argument (at least one version) is apparent as follows:

(1) A universe with natural disasters exists.
(2) A universe with natural disasters and an all-loving god cannot both exist.
(3) An all-loving god does not exist.

Here, although it was not initially explicit, an argument was formed. This is not merely an opinion or an assertion someone made, but rather is an argument. If, in the previous two cases, premises (1) and (2) are true, conclusions (3) must follow; previously shown were simple deductive arguments which are inescapable if the premises are true.

Returning to Zvan, Zvan refers to PZ's previously mentioned thoughts concerning abortion in a post titled "The only abortion argument that counts." His thoughts, restated -- what Zvan seems to be considering as PZ's argument -- are, broken down by numbers which I will utilize, as follows:
(4) We can make all the philosophical and scientific arguments that anyone might want, 
(5) but ultimately what it all reduces to is a simple question: do women have autonomous control of their bodies or not? 
(6) Even if I thought embryos were conscious, aware beings writing poetry in the womb (I don’t, and they’re not), 
(7) I’d have to bow out of any say in the decision the woman bearing responsibility has to make.
(4) is a mere assertion PZ makes in which he states that philosophical and scientific arguments do not matter because (5) he believes that the issue of abortion reduces to a simple question. This is merely a reflection of what PZ thinks. There are no premises leading to a conclusion here; there is no argument.

(6) is a hypothetical statement PZ proposes and (7) is an assertion that PZ would not make decisions concerning abortions but instead would "bow out of any say in the decision the woman bearing responsibility has to make."

Recall PZ's assertion that arguments do not matter in the case of abortion. PZ may be providing a conclusion of what could be an argument (abortion reduces to 'a simple question' of whether women have autonomous control of their bodies), but he isn't providing an argument.

If PZ were to say, "Abortion is moral/legal if and only if women have autonomous control of their bodies. Since women have autonomous control of their bodies, abortion is moral/legal," PZ would be advancing an argument, but PZ had said in his post that abortion reduces to a 'simple question' irrespective of argument.

Most of Zvan's post, then -- considering she mentions "PZ's argument" -- seems to reduce to nonsense. Apart from this, her post seems extremely unclear. She also references arguments Sam Harris provides, but said arguments aren't present in the post. (Must we read something beyond the post to discover what Harris' arguments are before reading this post? Why wouldn't she just state the arguments in her post?)

She also makes some odd comments surrounding thought experiments which, by their very nature, are hypothetical, imagined situations. She writes, referring to Sam Harris (although not identifying what Harris' counter-factuals are), "Harris draws conclusions that depend directly on his counter-factuals." Drawing conclusions that depend directly on counter-factuals seems to be the precise nature of and reason for, in many cases, proposing thought experiments.

For example, consider a thought experiment involving a fat man standing atop train tracks who, if pushed off, would prevent the death of five other people. (If the fat man were standing, then five people would not die). If you arrived at a conclusion based on my thought experiment such as 'It is sometimes moral to push a fat man off train tracks if this would prevent the deaths of five other people,' you drew a conclusion that depended directly on counter-factuals.

Conclusions reached through thought experiments, contrary to what Zvan seems to think, actually do have an impact on the 'real world' and directly inform our moral reasoning. Thomson's "A Defense of Abortion" paper, as previously mentioned, is a great example.

I'm further confused by Zvan mentioning what seem to be meaningless or contradictory statements when she writes [about]
  • counter-factuals "being wrong" 
  • a counter-factual, "despite the bizarre nature of the idea" being false
  • "hypotheticals, contradicted by real-world data, used [...] for purposes of illustration
  • "counter-factuals" being "factual"
  • Harris being told "his counter-factual was wrong and why"
Feel free, as always, to leave your thoughts.

Surly Amy: Conferences should ban 'fake jewelry'

Image provided by Reap Paden
[The original "This is what a feminist looks like" Surly-Ramics image has been removed from this post due to a DMCA complaint. I have replaced that image with the one you now see above. This post is also available on Youtube and Scribd.]

--

Skepchick writer and Surly-Ramics creator 'Surly Amy' has recently argued that conferences should ban 'fake jewelry' after recounting her recent TAM experience in which she spoke of a group of "very vocal angry troll-like people that did some really awful things" to her. I argue that placing restrictions on freedom of expression and speech would be unreasonable and disastrous. The mere suggestion of banning 'fake jewelry,' I argue, should disqualify 'Surly Amy' from being a participant in discussion concerning anti-harassment policies.

'Surly Amy' -- blogger for the Skepchick network and creator of 'Surly-ramics' jewelry -- has recently appeared on the August 5, 2012 episode of Amanda Marcotte's "RH Reality Check" podcast to discuss feminism within the atheist movement. Of particular interest in this short podcast were Amy's comments on her experience at The Amazing Meeting and thoughts on anti-harassment policies at atheist/skeptic conferences. During the discussion, Amy had said that she -- and presumably other feminists in the atheist community because she uses the word 'we' -- wants conferences to have rules restricting particular types of jewelry people wear. For instance, Amy says atheist/skeptic conferences should have policies which restrict "fake jewelry" which is "intentionally offending."

Near the 11:53 mark of the before-mentioned podcast, commenting on her experience at The Amazing Meeting, 'Surly Amy' said,
There was this group of, again, very vocal angry troll-like people that did some really awful things to me in real life - that sort of thing that you usually only see online I was actually face to face with. I had people wearing t-shirts saying that they were not a skepchick, people making fake jewelry that I make that said things on it like 'you should be embarrassed.' There's this really crazy undercurrent of othering that I had never experienced before and it was really upsetting and I ended up leaving the event a day early.
It seems that 'Surly Amy' considers people wearing t-shirts she doesn't like and jewelry saying 'you should be embarrassed' to be indicative of "very vocal angry troll-like people" and people acting "really awful" (she doesn't take time to mention anything else which warranted these labels and conclusions). This also apparently constitutes a "really crazy undercurrent of othering" which, at least in part, caused her to leave the conference a day early.

Further commenting, near the 14:22 mark in the podcast, Amy mentions what she would like to see anti-harassment policies at conferences to address. She explains,
We're not asking for anything crazy - just basic rules so that we can say the sort of thing like making fake jewelry and intentionally offending people is not okay nor is grabbing someone's ass. That's it, that's all we're asking for.
What, anyway, is 'fake jewelry?' Since when did 'Surly Amy' have an exclusive hold on the market of ceramic jewelry? 'Fake jewelry,' it seems, is ceramic jewelry either meant to satirize Surly Amy's jewelry or ceramic jewelry which is not made by 'Surly Amy.' One example of this 'fake jewelry,' according to a JREF forum poster is as follows: "The fake Surlys I saw looked like a man and woman standing on either side of an elevator with a big red slash through the whole picture." Anyway, returning to the issues...

It is reasonable for one to not only claim offense to 'fake jewelry,' but also to ask conferences to have policies which restrict what jewelry people wear...because someone like 'Surly Amy' happens to claim offense?

'Surly Amy' -- and apparently others in the atheist/skeptic community -- seemed to, for whatever reasons, have moved away from the common response of "Too bad, that's your problem" when someone claims offense. This is, at least from my experience, the reaction that many atheists have when religious people claim offense. For whatever reason, 'Surly Amy' and others seemed to have compartmentalized this attitude (assuming that she and others would respond to religious believers who happen to claim offense to atheists/skeptics arguing against religious claims or otherwise being blasphemous) and afforded some sort of special rules for their own particular sensitivities. Note that 'Surly Amy' does not only condemn that which she finds offensive, but she also wants to squelch others' freedom of speech at conferences by encouraging conferences to adopt policies restricting messages displayed on jewelry.

Banning others' speech because one happens to claim offense or dislike speech seems to be 'the coward's way out' that is often condemned by the atheist/skeptic community. What ever happened to "I might not like what you have to say, but I will defend your right to say it?" What ever happened to toleration and an understanding that other people should be afforded with the rights to express viewpoints which some might not  like? What sort of 'freethought response' is banning speech and insisting that conferences adopt policies which restrict messages on jewelry?

What sort of consequences might follow if "I'm offended" is good reason for conferences to adopt policies restricting jewelry people wear? Should 'Teach the Controversy' t-shirts which mock creationists be barred from conferences should a creationist happen to attend a skeptic conference and complain? Should critical examination of Islam and pictures of Mohammad be barred from atheist conferences should a liberal Muslim happen to attend and complain? Should Tim Minchin's "The Pope Song" be barred because people happen to take offense to vulgar language?

Skeptical readers may think that all of these consequences would not follow because these cases are 'different' or otherwise aren't attacking persons. This reasoning, though, would ignore the fact that offense is a largely (or perhaps totally) subjective term. After all, many are lauding Matt Dillahunty's recent "speaking out against hate directed at women" post which says,
When you hear a complaint that someone has raised, you might think that they're expressing an irrational, emotional, over-reaction to the situation. You might even be correct - but it doesn't matter, and here's why: You don't get to decide what someone else finds offensive. You don't get to decide what someone else finds uncomfortable, unwelcoming, disconcerting, stressful, harassing, troubling or painful. You aren't the world: everyone isn't exactly like you. We're trying to build a safe and welcoming community. We're trying to sponsor safe and welcoming events. [...] We need to make sure that people who express their concerns are treated with respect and compassion and that we make reasonable efforts to either alleviate their concerns or clarify why we can't or won't. 
Apparently, persons are -- according to Dillahunty's accounting -- out of line to argue that people are acting irrationally when they happen to "express a concern that something is making them feel unwelcome." Dillahunty, though, at least says that concerns can't or won't be addressed. The idea that people may not rightly challenge others who are behaving irrationally is poisonous and ought to be challenged by skeptics. The mere claiming of offense or taking an attitude of 'I believe it, so it is so' is no justification for one to place restrictions on others' behaviors.

If 'Surly Amy' and others had their way -- according to what 'Surly Amy' said in this podcast and logical conclusions which seem to follow -- conferences would ban others' freedom of expression and speech on grounds of a person claiming offense. I hope this day never comes, but it might just be on its way if people continue to consider 'Surly Amy' as a valid participant in the discussion concerning anti-harassment policies at conferences. Her wanting to restrict which jewelry people wear at conferences, though, should hopefully disqualify her from this discussion. Is this the sort of feminism that is worth wanting? 'Surly Amy,' after all, is not some 'rogue voice' or 'extremist' who has little clout; she is a well-respected and listened to voice within in the feminist atheist community.

Are you, reader, in agreement with 'Surly Amy?'
Should jewelry which leads people to claim offense be banned from conferences?

Related posts:
Disagree? "Fuck off and die" says FTB/Skepchick commenter 'Spokesgay'
In which I am ridiculed by PZ Myers
"Women and the Secular Community" discussion available
'Surly Amy,' Skepticism, and Satire
Stephanie Zvan doesn't understand cyberstalking
My Twitter conversation with Rebecca Watson...and much more

Sam Harris rebukes "shepherd of internet trolls" PZ Myers


Sam Harris has published a new blog post titled "Wrestling the Troll" in which he describes that, for him, there is "no effective way to respond" to many of his critics who uncharitably interpret his ideas. Harris says that he'd rather, in some cases, simply ignore the criticisms because people haven't initially taken the time to read what he had to write and are intellectually dishonest. Harris, in his post, specifically addressed one of his uncharitable critics -- and one person I have increasingly seen as being quite uncharitable -- PZ Myers.

Harris mentions an article on Alternet, "The 5 Most Awful Atheists," (also reproduced in Salon) in which his views were misrepresented and notes that "that shepherd of Internet trolls PZ Myers" [author of an "odious blog"] has "gleefully endorsed" the article "amplifying its effect." Harris writes,
In fact, people like PZ Myers continue to malign me as an advocate of "racial profiling." I have written to Myers personally about this and answered his charges publicly. His only response has been to attack me further and to endorse the false charges of others. I do not think I am being especially thin-skinned to worry about this. Accusations of racism and similar libels tend to stick online. If my daughter one day reads in my obituary that her father "was persistently dogged by charges of racism and bigotry," unscrupulous people like PZ Myers will be to blame.
Continuing, Harris writes,
It is difficult to overlook the role that blog comments play in all this. Having a blog and building a large community of readers can destroy a person’s intellectual integrity—as appears to have happened in the case of PZ Myers. Many people who read his blog come away convinced that I am a racist who advocates the widespread use of torture and a nuclear first strike against the entire Muslim world. The most despicable claims about me appear in the comment thread, of course, but Myers is responsible for publishing them. And so I hold him responsible for circulating and amplifying some of the worst distortions of my views found on the Internet.


I have been a fan of PZ Myers for some time and was especially happy that he promoted my content/activism concerning the legal threats I received for offering criticism about a local chiropractor named Dan Golaszewski and the refusal of the "Atheists." bus ads which made national news. I was happy to meet PZ at American Atheists' 2012 annual conference and had a picture taken with him after some discussion (see above).

In recent weeks and months, though -- especially following the vicious attacks on D.J. Grothe, The Amazing Meeting, and the James Randi Educational Foundation from many writers on the Freethought Blogs network -- I have noticed an extremely low level of discourse at PZ's blog. Looking back, I have noticed that his attacks on fellow secularists Michael de Dora, Edwina Rogers, Chris Stedman, Massimo Pigliucci, and many more (from both PZ and his commenters) are reprehensible and not conducive to community building, rational discourse, or respectful discourse. I've also been the target of ridicule at the hands of PZ.

It's quite a shame...especially considering the recent call for male leaders in the atheist community to rebuke 'hate directed toward women' from 'Surly Amy' writing for the Skepchick network. Apparently, hate directed toward women is unacceptable (unless your name is Edwina Rogers) but hate directed at others is perfectly fine.

Perhaps PZ and many Freethought Blogs commenters should take a lesson in civility and respect from fellow Freethought Blogs blogger Dan Fincke. If we want to demand respect from others and encourage a civil atmosphere free of personal attacks, name-calling, and insults, it would probably be best to emulate that behavior and create an environment in which civil behavior is called for. PZ, though, quite unfortunately does not seem to be interested in that. He and his commenters may direct hate at whomever they please, but when internet trolls happen to make nasty comments about Rebecca Watson and her fellow Skepchicks...well, that's just unacceptable.

This isn't to say, though, that the hate emanating from PZ Myers' blog and comment sections when compared to the hate women in the secular community receive are equal. I wouldn't even know this can be 'measured,' anyway. There seems, though, to be a problem when the "shepherd of internet trolls" (as Harris calls PZ) is engaged in a great deal of hate-mongering and character attacks along with his respective commenters. Why not extend the rebuking 'hate directed toward women' campaign to all persons and call for a global civility within the atheist/skeptic online community? Would PZ be interested in toning it down, rebuking his commenters, and committing to a respectful environment? Probably not.