About

Showing posts with label NEPA Freethought Society bus campaign. Show all posts
Showing posts with label NEPA Freethought Society bus campaign. Show all posts

Support for "Atheists." bus ad from local resident

Supportive e-mail from local resident
Last night, I received a supportive e-mail from a resident of Northeastern Pennsylvania (presumably from Scranton) who would like to see the "Atheists" bus ad I proposed back in January [this is the prototype/mockup] on Lackawanna County buses. For those who may have missed the story, I proposed a very simple bus ad containing the word "Atheists." and the url/name of my local freethought group...and was rejected on grounds that it was 'an attack on religion,' 'would start a public debate about controversial issues,' and more. Friendly Atheist Hemant Mehta called this ad -- and rightly so -- the most inoffensive atheist bus ad ever.



I haven't given up, either, even after being rejected two times; I am currently working with an organization to resolve this issue by placing the ads on county buses. Time will tell...

For the full story, click here for the 'living narrative.'

Bus company that refused "Atheists." ad back in the news


Above is the final version of the advertisement that the County of Lackawanna Transit System (COLTS) won't allow on their buses. Many readers of this blog likely know that I, months ago -- as a representative of the NEPA Freethought Society -- submitted a very simple ad containing the word "Atheists." that was rejected by COLTS.
--

Here's a quick summary of this, to refresh some memories, from a previous post on the matter:


This ad -- with the intention of being a really, really, really inoffensive ad sparked by a post written by Richard Wade writing for Friendly Atheist and a collaboration between atheist activist Carl Silverman and myself -- was partially a response to the "God Bless America" messages that had appeared on COLTS' buses and a test, if you will, of COLTS' highly subjective advertising policy.

When talking to a reporter regarding the rejection of the "Atheists." ad, another solicitor from COLTS -- Joseph DeNaples -- referring to COLTS' advertising policy, says COLTS does not accept ads "that are objectionable, controversial or would generally be offensive to COLTS' ridership" as determined by the agency.

The same article with the previous comments from DeNaples said,
Mr. DeNaples said NEPA Freethought Society's ad was rejected on the basis of another, broader provision in the policy. "Finally, it is COLTS' desired intent not to allow its transit vehicles or property to become a public forum for dissemination, debate or discussion of public issues," the provision says. Based on Mr. Vacula's stated intention to "test" the advertising policy, along with other statements on his and the society's websites, COLTS concluded the purpose of this ad was to promote debate and turned it down, Mr. DeNaples said. "It's clear to us that his intent is to spur some type of debate about religious views or non-religious views, and it's not our position to advance or promote or prohibit it," he said.
Executive Director of COLTS, Bob Fiume, said,  "It's the board's intent not to allow COLTS transit vehicles or property to be a forum for debate and that's what COLTS deemed these ads would be."

After I attended a board meeting in which I, during the 'public comment' section, expressed my disapproval of COLTS' rejection and pleaded that COLTS reconsider, COLTS solicitor Timothy Hinton made comments about the issue for a local newspaper article. The article explains, "COLTS solicitor Timothy Hinton reiterated the agency's position Tuesday, saying the ad proposed by the NEPA Freethought Society would violate an advertising policy adopted in June in which COLTS stated its intent not to allow its buses to become a forum for the dissemination or debate of public issues.

--

Today, COLTS happened to be in two articles in the Scranton Times-Tribune. One article titled "COLTS eliminates North Pocono route, alters others in restructuring" details about how and why COLTS is eliminating not only its North Pocono route, but also several other routes. The article explains:
As part of a comprehensive route restructuring that will go into effect July 2, COLTS is eliminating its North Pocono/Daleville route and curtailing service on at least four others. On the flip side, several routes have been expanded to include more hours or additional stops.
In addition to concerns voiced by COLTS in this article, COLTS has been considering (and eventually will implement) fare increases because of economic woes. A PDF on their website explains,
The County of Lackawanna Transit System (COLTS) plans to increase its fares and will hold a series of public hearings to present its plans to the community... 
"Our short term-goal is to increase fares to the rate of inflation, but we are sensitive to the economic impact this will have on its riders so we are looking at a two-pronged approach over two years," said Executive Director Robert Fiume."
This is quite interesting in the light of COLTS refusing the "Atheists." bus ad considering that our 'dirty atheist money,' although it certainly won't fix all of their problem, would help COLTS' economic situation. Tom Borthwick, a local blogger who commented on COLTS' refusal of the "Atheists." ad, concluded his commentary noting, "As a resident of Lackawanna County, I want COLTS to take that ad revenue. God knows we need it."

Another article, "Settlement reached between COLTS and ex-employee over workplace sexual harassment claims," recounts events pertaining to a women claiming a COLTS supervisor's alleged sexual harassment toward a COLTS employee. The article explains,
A federal lawsuit brought by a former County of Lackawanna Transit System receptionist claiming a supervisor sexually harassed her has been settled, according to an order issued Wednesday by U.S. District Judge Robert D. Mariani dismissing the case. 
Mary Ann Casale of Taylor sued COLTS in November alleging former transportation supervisor Anthony Koloras made inappropriate references about her breasts, told her that she "would not believe the things" he could do to her sexually, and kept pressuring her to give him painkillers that she had been prescribed after a surgery. 
[...] 
Ms. Casale, who resigned in 2009, also claimed COLTS made no effort to meaningfully look into or stop the harassment, subjecting her to a hostile work environment. She also alleged she complained about Mr. Koloras' behavior to the agency's former executive director in 2007 and 2008, but the harassment continued.

It's not looking good for COLTS...and they'll soon be back in the news.

Recap, Design Change concerning "Atheists." bus advertisement

Above is an image of the newest design of the bus ad the NEPA Freethought Society wishes to advertise on County of Lackawanna Transit System (COLTS) buses in Scranton, PA.



This post contains a recap (see under Recap) of many events thus far pertaining to why COLTS denied a bus ad that prominently features the word "Atheists." Following the recap is an explanation (see under Design Change) for why the design of the ad changed and why American Atheists has been removed from the billboard.

Recap

As many know, the "Atheists." bus advertisement has previously been denied.

This ad -- with the intention of being a really, really, really inoffensive ad sparked by a post written by Richard Wade writing for Friendly Atheist and a collaboration between atheist activist Carl Silverman and myself -- was partially a response to the "God Bless America" messages that had appeared on COLTS' buses and a test, if you will, of COLTS' highly subjective advertising policy.

When talking to a reporter regarding the rejection of the "Atheists." ad, another solicitor from COLTS -- Joseph DeNaples -- referring to COLTS' advertising policy, says COLTS does not accept ads "that are objectionable, controversial or would generally be offensive to COLTS' ridership" as determined by the agency.

The same article with the previous comments from DeNaples said,
Mr. DeNaples said NEPA Freethought Society's ad was rejected on the basis of another, broader provision in the policy. "Finally, it is COLTS' desired intent not to allow its transit vehicles or property to become a public forum for dissemination, debate or discussion of public issues," the provision says. Based on Mr. Vacula's stated intention to "test" the advertising policy, along with other statements on his and the society's websites, COLTS concluded the purpose of this ad was to promote debate and turned it down, Mr. DeNaples said. "It's clear to us that his intent is to spur some type of debate about religious views or non-religious views, and it's not our position to advance or promote or prohibit it," he said.
Executive Director of COLTS, Bob Fiume, said, "It's the board's intent not to allow COLTS transit vehicles or property to be a forum for debate and that's what COLTS deemed these ads would be."

After I attended a board meeting in which I, during the 'public comment' section, expressed my disapproval of COLTS' rejection and pleaded that COLTS reconsider, COLTS solicitor Timothy Hinton made comments about the issue for a local newspaper article. The article explains, "COLTS solicitor Timothy Hinton reiterated the agency's position Tuesday, saying the ad proposed by the NEPA Freethought Society would violate an advertising policy adopted in June in which COLTS stated its intent not to allow its buses to become a forum for the dissemination or debate of public issues.

Design Change

I feel that the issue of the design change must be addressed because people will wonder why the design changed and would ask questions regarding the design change.

Following a convening of the NEPA Freethought Society's board of directors due to some differences with American Atheists -- particularly concerning the actions of American Atheists' Pennsylvania State Director Ernest Perce concerning the issue of the bus ad -- the NEPA Freethought Society will no longer be working with American Atheists regarding the issue of the "Atheists." ad and the County of Lackawanna Transit System.

While I have had some personal disagreements with Perce [quite recently], the reasons for the NEPA Freethought Society's schism with American Atheists regarding COLTS and the "Atheists." ad are largely based on the way Perce had been handling the issue in his capacity as the Pennsylvania State Director of American Atheists. I do not, though, wish to elaborate on these issues in this post. Please understand that. I do not wish to get into a he said/he said 'battle' of sorts with Perce concerning this issue and don't feel that this would be very constructive. Hopefully, Perce does not want to start that battle.

The NEPA Freethought Society had given an option for American Atheists to remain on the billboard, but we have not received a response. Considering the letter was sent via e-mail to David Silverman on Match 31 and the sole post regarding COLTS on the "No God Blog" has been removed, this appears to be a 'no.' Regardless, the NEPA Freethought Society's leadership team has decided -- after the letter was sent -- to remove American Atheists from the billboard.

The NEPA Freethought Society had sought legal representation from other sources following a letter I had sent to David Silverman informing him of the NEPA Freethought Society's decision to no longer work with American Atheists regarding COLTS and the "Atheists." advertisement. I have not heard back from Silverman following the letter and am assuming that he has read the letter considering that the "No God Blog" post concerning COLTS has been removed.

Additionally, the NEPA Freethought Society never had any sort of contract pertaining to working with American Atheists on this issue and no legal work had been performed. The NEPA Freethought Society had hoped to work with American Atheists on this issue, but, as I explained, differences have terminated that relationship. The NEPA Freethought Society -- and its sought legal representation -- will be continuing efforts to make this bus ad a reality.

Previous blog posts of mine mentioning American Atheists' suppport of the ad have been removed and pictures of the ad have been modified.

More announcements are to come.

[Another] COLTS bus driver complains about "God Bless America" removal, but no support for "Atheists." ad

The message of "God Bless America," quite loud and proud, was displayed on COLTS' buses for years, but the "Atheists." ad isn't allowed. A bus driver, writing a letter to the editor of a local newspaper, complains about the removal of "God Bless America," but he voices no support for atheists. Shouldn't we be allowed to advertise the fact that we exist...? Is that too much to ask?
A bus driver for the County of Lackawanna Transit System (COLTS), Vincent Cerullo, wrote a letter to a local newspaper in Scranton expressing his disagreement with his employer and -- without arguing that I should have freedom of speech/the right to advertise the NEPA Freethought Society's "Atheists." ad inspired in part by Richard Wade and atheist activist Carl Silverman on county buses -- that COLTS should return the "God Bless America" message on its buses that was taken down after I had filed a complaint with the Freedom From Religion Foundation and wrote an article concerning the matter.

Cerullo writes,
Justin Vacula wants to advertise for atheists on COLTS buses, which are operated by Lackawanna County. He is up in arms because the COLTS board of directors will not allow this request. He has threatened a lawsuit and has soaked up media attention.

The COLTS drivers are no longer allowed to put "God Bless America" on the head signs of the buses because of this. We have been proudly advertising this for years and we should still be able to show this on the bus.

The COLTS board should recognize its error and go back to putting "God bless America" on the buses.

Of course, if COLTS allowed Mr. Vacula to advertise his atheist website, he would have to pay for it with money that says "In God We Trust."

The COLTS board can make a stand and do the right thing.

The bus driver assumes that "God Bless America" was taken down because I wanted an advertisement with the word 'Atheists' which COLTS' solicitor and other personnel have deemed -- despite its intentionally uncontroversial nature with the purpose of being the most inoffensive atheist bus ad ever -- an attack on religion and a debate about public issues.

The "Atheists." ad, though, was not the reason "God Bless America" was taken down. According to the Vice President of the union representing COLTS, the "God Bless America" message was removed because -- regardless of the merit of this reason -- people can find the message to be offensive...and presumably the board of directors made this decision.

Surely there was a problem with "God Bless America" being on buses...or otherwise COLTS would not have taken it down, right? We see, from the Vice President's comment, that there was a problem [and it was not because the "Atheists." ad was submitted]. It could, though, be the case that COLTS did this in response to me proposing the "Atheists." ad (as the bus driver asserted), but that's not what COLTS or the union's Vice President is saying. Is the bus driver really writing this letter to the editor in a local newspaper publicly saying that COLTS and the union's Vice President, are being dishonest or lying?

The crucial question for COLTS, though, is this: If COLTS has acknowledged that there are sufficient reasons for not having the "God Bless America" messages, why is this a sudden epiphany? Surely the same reasons for taking the "God Bless America" signs down would have been enough justification to do so right after they went up on buses years ago. Why should it take a complaint to remove the message?

Is it the case that COLTS/the bus drivers were fine with putting the message of "God Bless America" up -- that they now consider impermissible -- only because they weren't 'called out on it...or have they not been aware of "God Bless America" being a problem on a bus funded by state, county, and federal funds?

I find it quite humourous and disturbing that this bus driver is complaining about "God Bless America" being absent from the bus (and that he's writing a letter to a local newspaper in open disagreement with his employer who is doing the wrong thing), but he didn't mention support of the "Atheists." ad being on the bus.

I have contacted the bus driver via his Facebook profile (yesterday) to discover what his stance is (and he still hasn't responded), but considering his jabs at atheists it is probably the case that he wants "God Bless America," but he doesn't want the "Atheists." ad on the buses.

Funny stance, that is. Worry not about the freedom of speech of atheists concerning this issue. The freedom of speech of Christians is all that seems to matter to this bus driver. I am sorry to burst the driver's bubble, but atheists are citizens too. Is being allowed to advertise a group and reach out to fellow atheists really so much to ask? Do we really strike fear in your hearts considering that an all-loving, all-knowing, all-powerful god is supposed to be on your side? Is your faith that weak that it can't withstand a simple bus ad that isn't even questioning religion? Sorry, but your twisted ideas of freedom of speech and your religious beliefs are no good reason to censor atheists.

In a final really weak jab at me, the driver writes that the money I would give to COLTS would say "In God We Trust," but it can always be crossed out with a permanent marker...and a check or credit card would likely be the 'tender.' This assertion is almost as silly as the appeal to tradition the bus driver evokes. Because the ads were up for so long and it has allegedly not been a problem before I mentioned something, the ads must be permissible! Not so much.

I'd like to see some bus drivers supporting the "Atheists." ad.

Perhaps I will be waiting a long time, though...and there are now two bus drivers (the other being Daniel Wittenbreder) who have been public in one way or another about their disapproval.

Time is ticking for COLTS.

What will their decision be?

Are they really going to go to court and waste taxpayers' money considering that the county, on some accounts, is broke/bankrupt and the bus fares must raise to keep COLTS in business...over a simple advertisement that has the word "atheists" on it? What are the priorities of this county and board of directors? It is quite the odd situation, I think, when a governmental entity refuses funds. Apparently, our dirty stinking atheist money (which will be at least one thousand dollars) -- with or without "In God We Trust" -- is no good for them.

Christian Post: "Atheist Pleads Freedom of Speech Violations After Rejected Bus Ad"

Stoyan Zaimov, a writer for the Christian Post, has authored an article regarding -- as the title implies (and readers of this blog would rightly assume) -- the recent controversy surrounding the County of Lackawanna Transit System's (COLTS) refusal of the "Atheists." bus ad. Read the article here.

Interestingly enough, COLTS' solicitor has gone on the record claiming this advertisement -- an innocuous content-free message -- is attacking religion. I wonder how the solicitor arrived at this conclusion. Zaimov writes,

Hinton, however, repeated: "We don't accept ads promoting any certain religion or religion in general, so we don't want to accept an ad attacking religion."

Greta Christina: "Atheists' Existence is "Controversial," "Sparks Public Debate"

Greta Christina has weighed in on the controversy surrounding the County of Lackawanna Transit System's (COLTS) refusal of the NEPA Freethought Society's "Atheists." bus ad. Read her blog post here.

Friendly Atheist: "Bus Company (Again) Rejects Ad Reading Simply 'Atheists'"

Following the most recent County of Lackawanna Transit System (COLTS) board meeting, Hemant Mehta has once again weighed in on COLTS' refusal of the NEPA Freethought Society's "Atheists." bus ad. Read his blog post here.

AP: "NE Pa. transit system again rejects atheist group's proposed ads on side of buses"

Once again, the Associated Press reports on the "Atheists." bus ad controversy. Read the story here.

Local television coverage: "COLTS Again Rejects Atheism Ad"



WNEP TV has, once again, reported on the controversy surrounding COLTS' refusal of the NEPA Freethought Society's "Atheists." bus ad.

Unfortunately, the video is no longer available.

Local print media - "COLTS stands firm on atheist ad"

David Singleton, writing for the Times-Tribune, published a story following today's County of Lackawanna Transit System (COLTS) board meeting. I attended the meeting thinking that COLTS would reconsider its refusal of the "Atheists." bus ad sponsored by the NEPA Freethought Society ...but my hopes were shattered when Timothy Hinton -- one of COLTS' solicitors -- said that COLTS is standing by its original decision to refuse our ads.

Read the Times-Tribune article for more information.

...and weigh in in the comments section because it is getting quite silly. Once again, people aren't realizing that this is a free speech issue and not a religious argument. The whole point of this ad was to be as inoffensive as possible and, for some reason, the NEPA Freethought Society is being labeled as being antagonistic and a 'hate group' by some commenters.

We're not giving up.

Austin Cline weighs in on COLTS controversy



Austin Cline has weighed in on the controversy surrounding the County of Lackawanna Transit System's (COLTS) refusal of the "Atheists." bus ad sponsored by the NEPA Freethought Society in a post titled "Can You Say "Atheist" in a Crowded Theater?" on atheism.about.com.

Read the full post here.

Reap Sow Radio - Discussion of COLTS controversy and more


The newest episode of Reap Sow Radio, at the time of this posting, features discussion about controversy surrounding the County of Lackawanna Transit System's (COLTS) refusal of the "Atheists." bus ad sponsored by the NEPA Freethought Society, the removal of "God Bless America" from COLTS buses, and the threats I have
received from COLTS bus driver Daniel Wittenbreder, and much more. After discussion of these issues, I speak with Reap -- in a very informal discussion -- to talk about these issues and more. Discussion concerning COLTS starts at the 15 minute mark.

Listen here.

"Transit System Refuses Bus Ad: Discrimination?" [The Luck Report]


I recently had spoken with local author Kenny Luck from The Luck Report concerning the controversy surrounding the County of Lackawanna Transit System's (COLTS) refusal of the "Atheists." bus ad sponsored by the NEPA Freethought Society.

Listen to the short podcast here:

COLTS bus driver to be disciplined


Three days ago, I had authored a post which had concerned threats/harassment/intimidation I had received from a person representing himself as a County of Lackawanna Transit System (COLTS) bus driver named Daniel Wittenbreder (who indeed exists). Daniel, writing on my Facebook profile, had posted "DONT YOU EVER SHOW YOUR FACE ON MY BUS YOU LITTLE PUNK" and told me "try it..." when I had said, "So, if I went on your bus at COLTS, would you refuse me?". Daniel, between both his profile and my profile, also had some choice phrases for me including "little punk," "you should be ashamed of yourself," "the lord jesus christ will take care of you," and an "atheist puke with an axe to grind."

These comments, coming from someone representing himself as a bus driver for an entity which receives state, county, and federal funding are completely unacceptable. While one could argue that comments like this are simply 'taking a stand' or 'expressing free speech,' the line is crossed when a person represents himself as a COLTS bus driver and expresses willingness to deny services on a public transit system...and that is why I filed this complaint. Atheists -- or anyone else because of religious belief or lack thereof -- should not have to experience this intimidation.

After I had received these messages from Wittenbreder, I had filed a police report with my local police department concerning Wittenbreder's comments. This morning, I received a message from COLTS' solicitor:
We have received your complaint about Daniel Wittenbreder. Mr. Wittenbreder’s comments to you on Facebook were not authorized by COLTS and they are inappropriate. He will face discipline by COLTS for making them if it is proven he actually made them. He has been informed not to deny you service on a COLTS bus because of your atheist beliefs or any other beliefs you have. He is to refrain from communicating with you concerning your privileges and/rights to utilize the COLTS bus services. If you are denied service on a COLTS bus or someone threatens to deny you service on a COLTS bus, please advise me immediately. Thank you.
While COLTS did not do the right thing concerning the refusal of the "Atheists." bus ad sponsored by American Atheists and the NEPA Freethought Society, COLTS has done the right thing in not standing for intimidation toward its customers. Hopefully COLTS will take another step in the right direction and authorize the "Atheists." ad!

Reap Paden weighs in on COLTS controversy


Reap Paden, a resident of California, is quite baffled by the recent happenings in Pennsylvania including but not limited to Senator Anthony Williams supporting a school voucher program in which money would go away from public schools and to private sectarian religious schools, Judge Mark Martin throwing out a case of harassment against a Muslim man who attacked 'Zombie Mohammad' Ernest Perce, the County of Lackawanna Transit System (COLTS) refusing the "Atheists." bus ad, and COLTS driver Daniel Wittenbreder "talking smack on my Facebook profile" daring me to come on his bus and calling me and other atheists "seeds of the antichrist."

Read Reap's blog post here.

Earlier this month, I wondered whether it is either the best or worst time to be an atheist in Pennsylvania. What do you think?

I receive intimidation from a COLTS bus driver



Daniel Wittenbreder, a person representing himself as a bus driver for the County of Lackawanna Transit System, is telling me to not to dare to show my face on his bus, calling me a "little punk," telling me that "I should be ashamed of myself, and calling me an "atheist puke." When I had asked him what he would do if I were to go on his bus, his response was "try it...." Later in the discussion, Daniel, responding to someone saying he'd join me on the bus, said, "...you will always be outnumbered, ALWAYS!!!" and "see ya on the road tomorrow."

Just when I had thought everything has settled down in recent days regarding the County of Lackawanna Transit System (COLTS) controversy concerning the refusal of the "Atheists." ad sponsored by the NEPA Freethought Society (and the associated removal...or perhaps not so much of the "God Bless America" message on the 'public relation signs'), I had realized that a person representing himself as a bus driver has been saying some nasty things about me (even on my own profile!) while representing himself as a bus driver for COLTS!


I had posted a video still of my recent interview on WBRE news and some comments by this person, "Daniel Wittenbreder," representing himself as a COLTS bus driver has some choice words to say about/to me (unedited),
DONT YOU EVER SHOW YOUR FACE ON MY BUS YOU LITTLE PUNK...DIDN'T MOMMY AND DADDY SHOW YOU ENOUGH LOVE GROWIN UP?? OR WERE YOU FORCED INTO RELIGION AND THIS IS YOUR PAY BACK??? YOU SIR , HAVE WAY TOO MUSH TIME ON YOUR HANDS... GET A LIFE!!! (emphasis mine)
After I had written, "Daniel, are you serious?", he had responded saying,
"So what's your problem is it "god" or "America"? Let me tell you without either one you sir would not be enjoying the freedoms you do today!!! You should be ashamed of yourself...but thats not for me to decide...as the lord jesus christ will take care of you!!!! Believe it!!! (emphasis mine)
I responded, "So, if I went on your bus at COLTS, would you refuse me?"

His response was,
try it... (emphasis mine)


On Daniel's profile, accompanied by a bus he presumably drives with "God Bless America" on the 'public relations sign,' Daniel writes,
Many men and women shed blood,sweat and even their lives so we can enjoy the freedoms we have in this great country....and I'll be damned if some atheist puke with an axe to grind is gonna tell me I can't be proud of my God and my country!!!! AMEN" (emphasis mine)
and

"My employer removed this option today due to some threats from a little punk....when will people stand up for what they believe!!!! Shame on you" (emphasis mine)

Returning to my Facebook profile photo,


Daniel said,
well, I see all your pals are chiming in here...so be it, but hear this....you will always be outnumbered....ALWAYS!!!! (emphasis mine)

Finnish blogger weighs in on "Atheists." bus ad controversy

A Finnish blogger named Juha Leinivaara has weighed in on the County of Lackawanna Transit System's (COLTS) refusal of the "Atheists." bus advertisement sponsored by American Atheists and the NEPA Freethought Society.

Use a browser with a translate function if you aren't proficient in Finnish!




Steve Corbett, "God Bless the ACLU"


WILK Newsradio host Steve Corbett, weighing in on the COLTS bus ad controversy, has published a blog post on WILK Newsradio's website. Good post, Steve! Thanks for the support! The reposted blog post, with attribution, is here. Tune in to Steve Corbett's show on WILK Newsradio from 3PM-7PM on weekdays.

Instead of hiring political cronies and arguing unconvincingly that such patronage saves taxpayers’ money, the new majority Democrat Lackawanna County commissioners should speak out about developing County of Lackawanna Transit System (COLTS) recklessness that might one day cost taxpayers far more money than the commissioners claim to save.

COLTS is the government-supported public bus service run by a board of directors whose members are appointed by the elected county commissioners. COLTS has decreed that they will determine what ideas they approve and what ideas they reject for advertising on the sides of the public transportation.

As soon as I heard the news, First Amendment violation alarms immediately went off in my head. But Commissioners Jim Wansacz and Corey O’Brien hit the snooze buttons on their brains.

When that happens, taxpayers pay. As if a 38 percent county tax increase isn’t bad enough, legal fees alone if this issue goes to court could break the public bank. If the county loses, which ACLU super lawyer Mary Catherine Roper is convinced they will, yet more public funds will be squandered by this new and vapid duo that promises to lead us to prosperity.

The matter at hand is relatively simple: A young local atheist who in the past raised hell about Christmas displays on government property has asked to pay for a bus ad that simply says “atheism” and provides a telephone number and website address for people who might want to make contact.

The COLTS board, however, set a policy in June that gives them the power to decide content in messages. Such content cannot provoke a public forum or discussion, particularly about matters of controversy, according to Gretchen Wintermantel, the COLTS spokeswoman with whom I spoke yesterday.

So COLTS rejected the young atheist’s bus ad.

Board members set the policy and the COLTS managers make the decision, Wintermantel said.

By the end of yesterday’s show, she had not responded to my email asking the names of the authority public servants who make these arbitrary and highly subjective political decisions. These decisions are, indeed, political, as are any and all decisions made by any and all government authorities that receive any and all funding from federal, state and county coffers – as does COLTS.

I asked spokeswoman Wintermantel if I could pay for a bus ad that displays my face and the name of my radio station. She said I could, even though I am more controversial than anybody in local media or politics, for that matter.

But she said COLTS would draw the free speech line if I expressed an opinion in the ad such as “I like guns” (which, of course I would never say, instead preferring something like “Impeach O’Brien and Wansacz.”

That’s where government censorship comes into play. That’s where the bills start to mount as visions of punitive damages dance in my head. That’s where First Amendment infringement rears its ugly head.

Witermantel said that she and one of two COLTS lawyers – more government political appointments, of course, who are called solicitors in the world of local government - put the policy together. When she reminded me that she once worked in journalism I fought the impulse to remind her that she must have forgotten everything she should have learned in the process.

I take my First Amendment rights as seriously as anybody. As a veteran journalist who once got arrested for my service to the First Amendment, a Lackawanna County taxpayer and good government advocate, I also take seriously bureaucratic ignorance that risks public money we don’t have to begin with.

Wansacz and O’Brien posture and preen and essentially do nothing to protect taxpayers or good government from abuse and waste. Neither commissioner has commented public on this dangerous hazard for county taxpayers. Expect more of the same.

So while the atheists and the ACLU decide how to play this one – after the ACLU won large legal fees in a recent similar case in Alleghany County – COLTS has another problem.

The vice president of the COLTS drivers’ union called “Corbett” yesterday to announce the COLTS management decision to order a driver to remove what the union official called a “public relations” message from the top front of his bus.

The message reads in lights, “God Bless America.”

The VP said he could not comment on the hypothetical of a driver posting a PR message that read, “Allahu Akbar,” or “God is the greatest” to those of the Muslim faith. But the union officials said he was concerned that the drive’s free speech might also be undermined by the forced removal of this patriotic and religious motto that the driver takes to heart.

Oh, we definitely got trouble, right here in the Electric City.

Like prophet Ken Kesey said, “Either you’re on the bus or you’re off the bus.”

Local blogger Tom Borthwick weighs in on "Atheists." bus ad controversy

Profile Picture

Writing for NEPartisan.com, local blogger Tom Borthwick weighed in on the "Atheists." bus ad controversy today showing support. Read the post here.

NEPArtisan is dedicated to providing insight, commentary, and news important to the Northeastern Pennsylvania community.

Administrators and Editors

Tom Borthwick graduated from Marywood University in 2004 with a BA in English. He holds both an MA and MFA in Creative Writing from Wilkes University, obtained in 2008 and 2009 respectively. Also, he likes talking politics.



The "Atheists." bus ad controversy is a free speech issue, not a religious argument


Arguments regarding the truth value of religious claims have entered the controversy surrounding the "Atheists." bus ad (see comments here) and some atheists in the comments section of the linked Times-Tribune article have taken the bait from some religious commenters who have levied personal attacks against atheists or otherwise have argued that there is good reason to believe that the Christian god exists. While I relish debates/discussions regarding the truth-value of religious claims [and have participated in a live recorded formal "Does the Christian god exist?" debate myself], view these discussions as very important, and encourage others to participate in said discussions, let us not be distracted from what the real issue is here surrounding COLTS: freedom of speech.

Whether a person happens be to be atheist, a theist, or something else should have no bearing whatsoever on rational arguments dealing with the issue of whether a bus company which receives state, federal, and county funds should (or otherwise be legally required to) provide equal access to citizens using advertisement space on their buses.

Since COLTS is not allowing the NEPA Freethought Society to advertise -- especially considering that our message is content-free -- it seems quite obvious that freedom of speech is being abridged and COLTS is not allowing equal access for citizens to advertise on their buses. Equal access is what a pluralistic society should aim for rather than selective speech. Unfortunately, it's all too often that atheists get 'the short end of the stick.'

In October of 2011, I authored a post for American Atheists' "No God Blog" titled "Equality for Atheists in the 'Marketplace of Ideas'" which is very relevant to the current situation with COLTS. I wrote that atheists have been facing discrimination in current times even when messages are 'really tame.' Whether we [atheists] march in Memorial Day paraders, fly banners in the month of July, or have billboards saying "Good Without God," I wrote, "the cacophony of complaints can be heard from Christians who want to censor us [atheists]."

Ending this post, I wrote
Atheists should have the same rights as Christians to present their ideas – within reason – in pluralistic societies. Messages should simply not be censored because those in a position of privilege and power happen to disagree, have negative impressions of atheists, or whatever reason. [...] [C]ensorship and exclusion is often the ‘order of the day.’ Silencing your‘opposition,’ though, is the coward’s way out.
Unfortunately, COLTS doesn't seem to understand that some people might hold beliefs that others might disagree with and, living in a pluralistic society, most of us have come to the very reasonable conclusion that persons simply have to 'deal with it' (and perhaps just 'grow up' and realize that this world is full of people who disagree) and government entities may not discriminate simply because they happen not to like a message (or content-free message).

It would be one thing if the NEPA Freethought Society wanted to advertise for the KKK or Aryan Youth (which we never would do, but let's consider this for the sake of argument), but this simply is not the case. We want to simply say, "we exist" and provide an audience with websites for our organizations. Atheists in Northeastern Pennsylvania and the rest of this world should not feel alone when vibrant communities of atheists exist. Is this too much to ask? Apparently, for COLTS, this fear(?) of a public debate about issues is a good enough reason to discriminate against atheists who want to advertise on buses and this public debate fear (?) outweighs all other concerns of [freedom of speech]. Shall this be the standard we live by a pluralistic democratic society?

While discussions about the truth value of religious claims are important (and certainly can and should be had), it's important -- for both theists and atheists -- to not consider this an issue of religious debate, but rather see it as a free speech issue. Whether you are an atheist or not or whether you like the fact that we intend to advertise or not, you should -- as you are a member of a pluralistic democratic society who presumably values your own free speech rights -- agree that COLTS should allow the really, really, really inoffensive "Atheists." ad and stand up for free speech...because that's the real issue here at the core of things.

The wonderful irony of the whole COLTS situation, as I posted as a Facebook status of mine, is that their refusal of the "Atheists." ad -- on grounds that it would cause a debate about public issues and that said debate is impermissible -- drew even more attention to the issue and actually started a debate about public issues! Even better than that, the refused ad -- probably because COLTS happened to refuse it -- has been featured in local and national news including the front page of Scranton's own Times-Tribune. COLTS' refusal has utterly backfired and the NEPA Freethought Society-- and everyone who stands in solidarity for freedom of speech -- is winning this war.


For more 'backstory' on the "Atheists." bus ad controversy before this post, please visit this link. Thanks for your support!