About

Showing posts with label tyler winstead. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tyler winstead. Show all posts

Humanism letter to the editor published

Bumper sticker from the Freedom From Religion Foundation

During my stay in Columbus for the Secular Student Alliance's 2012 annual convention, a local newspaper published a letter to the editor I had written concerning humanism and the (lack of) efficacy of prayer and supernatural pleas in regards to a pious pastor who attempted to address the problem of violence in Northeastern Pennsylvania. I have addressed this pastor, Rev. Michael Brewster, in previous posts on this website. Below is the letter.


Real solutions for real problems
Soon after Rev. Michael Brewster of Mount Zion Baptist Church commented about the shooting death of local youth Tyler Winstead – appealing to God to stop the violence in this community and talking about “employ(ing) the weapon of unconditional and radical love for humanity” – I called these comments vapid and a failure because they did not offer earthly solutions to earthly problems. 
As an atheist, and more specifically a humanist, I view these comments as contributing nothing to combat very real problems that ought to be addressed by human action. 
Humanists and atheists don’t look to “supernatural solutions” for earthly problems, but rather look to earthly solutions for earthly problems. Real action from people on their feet, rather than those in prayerful kneeling, is required for change. We find no good reason to believe that prayer solves any problems or that any gods – if they exist – intervene in human affairs. 
It is wonderful that Rev. Brewster recently has taken action by holding community meetings in conjunction with the “Building Bridges” initiative. It seems that many people in this community have realized that prayer is not sufficient to deal with our earthly problems. 
For those who believe that God only helps those who help themselves, it seems evident that people helping themselves can’t be distinguished from God helping people. And we all know which one is the more reasonable explanation.

More on WILK's Steve Corbett...and Rev. Brewster's grandstanding



Recently, WILK Newsradio host Steve Corbett attacked me on his radio program and WILK's Facebook page because of my comments regarding Rev. Brewster of Mount Zion Baptist Church. I recently saw Corbett at a public education rally and was dismissed once again. Corbett didn't want to have a conversation in-person and never bothered to invite me on his show although he was quite happy to attack me on-air and on WILK's Facebook page even though I was vindicated after Rev. Brewster's town-hall meeting that he has promised was cancelled on two occasions.

Steve Corbett (pictured above), a self-professed liberal even though he endorsed McCain/Palin in the previous presidential election after Hilary lost her bid for the Democratic nominee for president, is a local newsradio host on WILK Newsradio -- a primarily conservative radio station which features the national figures of Michael Savage and Rush Limbaugh -- who recently attacked me on air dismissing me as a "professional atheist" and, on the WILK Newsradio Facebook page, used the phrases "self-absorbed sense of self-importance," "childish need for instant gratification," "get over yourself," and "grow up" addressing my comments concerning the grandstanding of a local preacher and the false hope he is giving to people of this community following the shooting death of a local 14-year-old boy. This was quite, on my estimation, unprofessional and rude [for a radio show host to say something like this to one of his listeners and frequent callers].

Yesterday, when I attended a public education rally, I saw Corbett and was utterly dismissed once again. I approached Corbett and, after introducing myself, told him that I was quite disappointed with his recent reaction to me. He replied, in quite a stern voice, saying, "I'm trying to listen to this" (referring to listening to a speaker at the rally). I stood next to him for about ten seconds, walked away, and saw, after I returned to where I had been standing, him walking away from where he was standing and speaking with other people (namely politicians in the audience). Apparently, once again, Corbett doesn't want to have a conversation and just wants to be dismissive.

When speaking with a friend about this issue, she noted something I really didn't think about at first. It is quite rude, she noted, for a radio show host to see one of his listeners at a public event and not have even a quick discussion. There was no "I'll talk to you after the rally" or "I'll talk to you after this speaker," but rather flat-out dismissal.

I find it quite interesting that Corbett -- a person who presents his radio show as an open forum for discussion of all sorts of ideas from all sorts of callers who are encouraged to call in -- is so dismissive in-person and on his radio show. To make matters even worse for Corbett -- considering he was so upset about what I had to say about the vapid words and grandstanding of Rev. Brewster (I'll get more into this later) -- he never even bothered to have me on his show despite my open nature and his possession (or quick googling of) my e-mail address.

I had noted, in my comments about Rev. Brewster that Corbett became so angry about, that Rev. Brewster was grandstanding in the name of his faith. I was recently even more vindicated on this matter. Rev. Brewster pledged to have a town hall meeting on Wednesday of last week to address violence in NEPA following the death of Tyler Winstead. The Wednesday meeting was cancelled and was delayed until Friday...and the Friday meeting never happened. I didn't see one media report on the meeting, a time or location was never announced, and Rev. Brewster has said nothing about it in local press [and he's been quite active there].

A recent article in The Times-Tribune noted:
As he promised during his Easter service, the Rev. Brewster said he was commissioning a town-hall meeting with city officials in the wake of Tyler's death to seek concrete solutions to the area's problems and not just rhetoric. He said he expected the same interest and attendance when it comes time to sit down and address the region's most pressing problems.
As we can now see quite clearly, Rev. Brewster's words were just rhetoric; he hasn't delivered on his promises of "concrete solutions to the area's problems" despite pledging to have a town hall meeting on specific dates. It seems that Rev. Brewster, as I said earlier this week, is just a grandstander. Steve Corbett was so angry when I had said that...and I was right. We still, though, need earthly solutions to our earthly problems.

I was dismissed as 'professional atheist,' 'insensitive,' 'self-absorbed' by local newsradio host



In my last two posts regarding the Christian response to the death of Tyler Winstead -- "The vapid Christian response to the death of Tyler Winstead" and "The failure of the Christian response to the death of Tyler Winstead", I argued that Rev. Michael Brewster's comments were vapid, did nothing to address problems of violence, and were problematic considering they offer false hope to people who believe they're actually doing something to address a problem. If you haven't read the posts, please take some time to read them so you can understand the context of this post.

Drawing on the comments from my two blog posts, I posted some comments on WILK Newsradio's Facebook page responding to this following status


Tyler Winstead's funeral packed the Mt. Zion Baptist Church with celebration, heartache and the promise of church-led community action to make Wilkes-Barre a better, peaceful city. What will it take for the dream to succeed? Talk to "Corbett" at 3 about the future.

addressing what I considered to be the vapid response of Rev. Brewster. It seems to be the case that people in the community are looking to Rev. Brewster from Mt. Zion Baptist Chruch for answers (the Facebook status even recognizes this noting "church-led community action"). Rev. Brewster has had many opportunities to lay out a plan of action as he has been promising, but so far all of his comments -- it seems -- were appeals to God and his faith. He even was said to have planned a town meeting for Wednesday...and that was cancelled! After discovering this, it seems that Brewster is grandstanding in the name of his faith as I note:

Rev. Brewster's words of change are vapid. According to news reports, his plan of action is to "employ the weapon of unconditional and radical love for humanity." Brewster also says that Tyler "is in the best hands he will ever be" seemingly asserting -- whether he realizes it or not -- that he is better off dead and allegedly in the hands of God than he is alive. Perhaps to even make matters worse, Brewster claims that God has forgiven the person who killed Tyler and that Tyler's family has also forgiven. I wonder...how can someone possibly forgive someone whom they do not even know the identity of?

The solutions to this problem will not be found by appealing to faith, some other alleged world, or a so-called 'holy man.' Instead of talking so much about an alleged God in his sermon, Brewster could have put forth real plans for responding to violence rather than "the weapon of unconditional and radical love."

Nothing fails like prayer.

and


It's an utter shame that Brewster is grandstanding in the name of his faith and offering false hope to those in Wilkes-Barre and NEPA who are looking for real change and not some empty words about God and "unconditional and radical love." I don't suppose to know or have the answers, but one thing is for sure - Brewster doesn't know or have the answers.

The person posting under the WILK Newsradio handle -- perhaps radio show Steve Corbett or perhaps not -- dismissed my comments and, instead of responding to the content of my posts or something similar, claimed that I "lack sensitivity for the grief of others."


Did you ever think that your lack of sensitivity for the grief of others might be one reason that some people will never take you as seriously as you would like, Justin?

The person posting under the WILK Newsradio handle also wrote the following and, once again, failed to respond to my content although this time levied personal attacks against me simply for, as it seems, objecting to Rev. Brewster's comments.


Ok, Justin. Your overrunning this exchange with your self-absorbed sense of self-importantc is simply not acceptable. This discussion is about a dead child, not your childish need for instant gratification. Get over yourself for at least a day. Grow up. Tyler does not have that chance.


Additionally, on live radio, radio show host Steve Corbett dismissed me as a "professional atheist" noting, if I recall correctly, that I am pushing an 'agenda against faith' and being disrespectful by posting on the Facebook page. [Unfortunately, the show isn't archived, so I can't link it.] Never mind, of course, the fact that I am a graduate student, a writer, a blogger, and do other things with my life. A commenter, also, on the NEPA Freethought Society's website wondered if me being a "professional atheist" is a reason to dismiss my comments should also lead people to dismiss "professional Christians."

It's quite unfortunate that whoever posted under the WILK Newsradio handle directed these comments at me when -- at the same time -- WILK Newsradio presents itself as an open forum for the discussion of ideas in which people are welcome to share their opinions. Apparently, some ideas are now simply 'out of bounds' and the words of Rev. Brewster are immune from criticism. Apparently, instead of responding to my comments, the tactic is now to just object to him even posting and levy personal attacks.

One thing I learned from the skeptical movement is that if one's ideas have merit, one should be able to counter others' ideas with ideas of their own by providing arguments rather than attacking the person making the arguments. Arguments stand or fall based on their merits, not the person making them. Apparently, even though my posts were so objectionable, the objectors didn't even bother -- for some reason -- to pose objections. Personal attacks are the order of the day, it seems.

It's even more interesting that not one single argument was made against what I was said -- or even regarding why I shouldn't type what I typed -- but rather people were objecting to the discussion even taking place to begin with and calling, for some reason, for me to 'respect beliefs' (in other words, sit down and shut up). The same person who is calling for me to be 'sensitive' is levying personal attacks at me using phrases such as "self-absorbed sense of self-importance," "childish need for instant gratification," "get over yourself for at least a day," and "grow up."

"Get over yourself for at least a day?" Excuse me? Are you honestly stating that my posting on a thread disagreeing with comments from a reverend and arguing that his comments are vapid is indicative of my entire character in which I am, on this accounting, "self-absorbed" with a "childish need for instant gratification?" Because, of course, writing eight-page papers concerning theological fatalism and writing about philosophy of science is really me being self-absorbed on every day of the week and me trying to fulfill my alleged childish need for instant gratification. One thing that will satiate my childish need for instant gratification, for sure, is writing about philosophy! That's the rub!

It's time for atheists -- and everyone else -- to call for an end to this extremely harmful meme of ideas being above criticism. How are we, as a society, supposed to progress if mere disagreement is unacceptable and the preferred method of choice is -- instead of responding to arguments with arguments -- personal attacks? Is that really going to get us anywhere? In the wake of the death of Tyler Winstead -- what the whole conversation even started because of -- people are calling for peace and love, but we're hardly seeing this from WILK Newsradio's comments. We can disagree and still be respectful of one another, but apparently that wasn't the case yesterday.

As always, I welcome comments and even disagreement. If you think that my comments are, for whatever reason, uncalled for or out-of-line, please post your reasons for thinking so, but don't attack me. Let's have a respectful discussion.

Additionally, if you'd like to add your thoughts to the WILK Newsradio thread on Facebook, feel free to do so here.

The failure of the Christian response to the death of Tyler Winstead

In a previous post, I analyzed and aggregated many of the comments some Christians in my community were voicing in response to the shooting death of a 14-year-old boy named Tyler Winstead. In particular (and as expected for better or for worse), Rev. Michael Brewster of Mount Zion Baptist Church received a great deal of coverage in the media and had a really good opportunity to offer some solutions to respond to violence in Northeastern Pennsylvania...but he blew it. Instead of offering some real-world solutions or attempts to ebb violence, Brewster used the opportunity to preach empty words and grandstand for his faith; Brewster noted that he would employ "the weapon of unconditional and radical love for humanity. Brewster also said that Tyler "is in the best hands he ever will be" and that God and Tyler's family have forgiven the person who was responsible for Tyler's death.


Before authoring my previous post -- and even commenting on the issue -- I considered whether I should comment and whether this is, as many say, 'a battle worth fighting.' Should atheists just 'leave the situation alone' and not respond to the often wild claims that theists are making that do absolutely nothing to rectify a situation? In this case, comments are not only of a grieving nature, but rather are -- at least in Rev. Brewster's case -- intended to actually do something to combat violence. When the solutions that are offered are vapid and do nothing, I feel some sort of responsibility to challenge the solutions and hold preachers -- who often never get challenged -- accountable.

It is quite clear that Rev. Brewster's solution of appealing to God has failed and is continuing to fail. When I was an active churchgoer and committed theist, I recall the daily 'prayers of the faithful' in which the persons speaking and presiding over the mass would petition God for changes in the world ending with "Lord, hear our prayers." On some occasions, I was even the person who had read these petitions from the podium. With all of the prayer going on -- and the parishioners who honestly believe that God intervenes in human affairs -- one would expect to see quite a different world than the one we see now...but we simply don't.

As Prince Prospero in the movie The Masque of the Red Death notes, "Famine, pestilence, war, disease, and death" 'rule this world.' If we can, instead of petitioning to a God and believing that our prayers are actually doing something, realize that earthly problems will only be solved by earthly beings, I would wager that much more would be accomplished and much less time would be wasted by those who falsely believe that their prayers are doing something to remedy a situation.

Religious persons and atheists often, for various reasons, ask, "What's the harm?" when considering prayer and pleas to God. This is it. People are led to believe that their words are doing something to change this world and that so-called 'holy men' who allegedly are called by and communicate with God are the beacons of hope that are needed to solve problems. 'Holy men' and parishioners can solve problems, but this won't be accomplished by kneeling and closing eyes. We need to open our eyes to the world around us and accept reality for what it is.

While it is certainly the case that some theists out there do not believe that their prayers will be answered by God and only believe that prayer is a meditation or reflection of sorts, we can't deny that many theists literally believe that their petitions can be answered by God and that their prayers are actually doing something to fix problems here on earth.

Many parishioners and pastors, sadly enough, are "Living a Lie" as the Epica song suggests with its very powerful chorus:

Hope is a desert running dry
Deep inside
You refuse to face the facts
But pray for life
Find salvation in distress
We will wait
For the day you break out and reawake

The vapid Christian response to the death of Tyler Winstead

5156065.jpg


For those who are not from Northeastern Pennsylvania -- or otherwise do not know -- a 14-year-old boy named Tyler Winstead was recently shot and killed while walking home from playing basketball at a Christian Youth Center by an assailant who is still at large and unknown. Local media has described Winstead as a "well-behaved church-going honors student" and noted that he was killed right outside of Mount Zion Baptist Church where he and his family attended. Tyler even sung in the church choir. As might be expected, many Christians -- including members of Tyler Winstead's family -- have commented on the death.

As an atheist and a theological non-cognitivist (one who believes god-language is empty in content), it should be quite obvious that I don't believe talking about God or appealing to any god is going to actually do anything about the recent shooting death besides offer false hope. In this case, it seems that the appeals to God -- as you'll see in this post -- actually hurt the situation and make people believe that something is being done to rightly address the shooting death...which is one of the main reasons why I am authoring this post.

Some atheists may object to me even writing this post or commenting on the issue (and some have) because of various reasons: they may want me to 'leave the family alone,' may believe that religious appeals are persons' only coping mechanisms, may believe that is is improper to criticize Christian beliefs considering the recent death, etc. I don't think these objections are sufficient especially considering people -- even those outside of Winstead's family -- honestly believe that their 'Christian solutions' will properly address the recent death...and they're willing to go on the record with their comments.

One of the first comments that was made 'on the record' regarding Tyler Winstead's death was from Tyler's grandfather, Willie Golden, who said,


We believe in God and his master plan - whether we understand it or not.

This comment is quite interesting concerning the implications that this statement makes which are as follows:
  • God -- an all-loving, all-powerful, and all-knowing being -- includes the shooting death of a 14-year-old boy in his 'master plan.'
  • Since God is all-loving, all-powerful, and all-knowing, his 'master plan' should be lauded because only all-good consequences can flow from an all-loving being. (Many Christians, from my experience, have argued or asserted that all judgments or actions stemming from God must accord with his all-loving character)
  • Since Tyler Winstead was killed as part of God's plan (and God is all-loving), this is actually -- as much as our moral intuitions may contend -- a good thing. [I'll get more into this later considering a pastor actually states that Tyler "is in the best hands he ever will be.]
I can't possibly believe in an all-loving, all-powerful, and all-knowing God who weaves -- as Golden says -- the shooting death of a 14-year-old boy into his 'master plan.' Instead of failing to understand the plan, we should instead assume the following: God's plan doesn't include the shooting death of a 14-year-old boy or God doesn't exist. How can one seriously contend that a shooting death of a 14-year-old boy coheres with the moral character of an all-loving, all-powerful, and all-knowing god?

Did God really send the shooter?

Other comments concerning 'God's plan' came from someone whom, incidentally, I had the pleasure of debating on a special episode of the NEPA Freethought Society Podcast. Rev. Marcelle Dotson, commenting on the death of Tyler Winstead, was quoted in an article saying,


I know the plans that I have for you, declares the Lord. They are plans for peace and not disaster.

I was quite confused by this comment, so I asked Rev. Dotson to clarify her statements. She said, on Facebook,

It's unfortunate that the Citizen's Voice did not include the comments that followed pertaining to that passage: That is is not God's plan that any life should be taken by another and that God intends a hopeful future for all. We are not to allow perpetrators of violent acts to hold us hostage and attempt to deny us a life of peace and justice.

Thankfully, Rev. Dotson doesn't believe that the shooting death of a 14-year-old boy is part of God's plan (although concerns of theological fatalism might force her to concede this, but that's a post for another day). This statement, though, seems problematic because Dotson contests that God intends a hopeful future for all. I cannot see how this is the case when God, whom many Christians believe created the universe, weaves natural disasters into the fabric of his design. I mentioned this in my debate with Rev. Dotson vis-a-vis the evidential problem of natural evil and Dotson's response seemed to appeal to the common 'you can't know the mind of God' defense that I believe dramatically fails.

Following Dotson's comments, Rev. Michael Brewster of Mount Zion Baptist Church -- who believes that atheists are adversaries of Christians who are trying to take away their power of prayer [listen to his sermon titled "Prayer: It's Importance in a Believer's Life" ...although it's no longer available (5/24/12)] -- had many words to say regarding the death of Tyler Winstead.

The Citizen's Voice article, "Church offers message of love in wake of teen's death," features many comments Rev. Brewster offered. The article begins, "...the community intends to fight back with a force far more potent than violence.


A large number of us have determined to engage with a fierce, and much more powerful weapon, the likes of which no evil has the power to withstand," Brewster said. "We'll employ the weapon of unconditional and radical love for humanity, and out right to live, and not only live, but our right to thrive in a community in peace, in this beautiful valley God has created, in this place we call our home. We intend to preserve it.

It's quite obvious that 'evil' has already had the power to withstand the supposed love and prayers Brewster and every member of his congregation have offered to God. God has, it seems, done absolutely nothing -- assuming he exists -- to prevent to death of Tyler Winstead. On some accounts, this death was even part of God's plan. The "powerful weapon" of "unconditional and radical love for humanity" in "this beautiful valley God has created" isn't going to stop the violence.

God, if he exists, despite all of the prayer and "unconditional and radical love for humanity" allowed Tyler Winstead to be killed at the age of 14. Free will, you say? Apparently, the 'free will' of the shooter was more important than Tyler's. Apparently, God's secret reason for allowing all of this famine, pestilence, slaughter, disease, and death outweighs every concern and desire humans have to be free from egregious suffering -- much of which has nothing to do with moral agents acting -- and we should just continue believing that an all-powerful, all-loving, all-knowing god exists despite the massive amount of evidence to the contrary.

Following the previous comments, Brewster said, of Tyler, during a moment of silence,


he is in the best hands he will ever be.

Apparently, on Brewster's account, Tyler is better off dead (and allegedly in the hands of God) than he is alive and in the hands of his loving family and friends. What 'message of love' is this?

To make matters even worse, Brewster says,


I want to say to those who are responsible for taking this precious life, I want you to know that despite what you've done, God has and always will love you. And he stands ready to forgive you, should you humble yourself and ask for his forgiveness. Furthermore, it is because of the message of Easter, which brings hope to all mankind, that the family, too, has chosen to love and to forgive you as well.

So, as we see, God loves and forgives people who kill 14-year-old children provided that they humble themselves and ask for forgiveness. What kind of morality and legitimate forgiveness is this? God, apparently, can forgive on the behalf of others (including the murdered victim) and a simple humbling and asking for forgiveness can make everything better. Additionally, the family, on Brewster's account, loves and forgives the shooter.

I don't know about you, reader, but I don't think I could possibly forgive a person who might happen to murder a 14-year-son of mine especially if I didn't even know the person, the person's motives, or other circumstances that were involved.

While Brewster and many others -- being persons of faith -- may appeal to their religious beliefs to cope with or otherwise address the death of Tyler Winstead, it's quite clear that appeals to religion and some other world aren't going to do anything in this situation. Instead of appealing to God or some other world, our concerns should remain in this one where only real solutions can be found. I don't have the answers, but it should be quite clear that Brewster's message of love -- as a response to the death of Tyler Winstead -- is a vapid one.