My "Does God Exist?" debate with Dr. Ronda Chervin - now available on Youtube!
Dr. Chervin presented variations of Aquinas' third and fifth ways in her opening statement.
I presented the evidential problem of natural evil, Stephen Law's 'Evil God Challenge,' and the problem of theological fatalism.
Thanks to all who supported, promoted, and watched the debate. Jason Gogola (behind the camera) and Karla Porter (the debate's moderator) helped with the organization and worked hard to make this happen. An extra special thanks goes out to my opponent, Dr. Chervin, for providing a good debate.
Comments, questions, and feedback -- always encouraged -- can be posted here. I will be participating in events like this in the future, so constructive criticism will help improve the quality of debates like this. Consider also sending e-mail and thanks to Dr. Chervin at ChervinRonda (at) gmail (dot) com. Feel free, also, to sound off on the event's Facebook page which still has ongoing discussion!
I will be dedicating some upcoming blog posts concerning this debate in which I will further develop the arguments I presented, restate and expand my objections to my opponent, and comment on some issues which were raised in the question and answer session. Stay tuned by following the blog label 'NEPAGodDebate' and keeping watch on my blog.
An interesting note which should be known...
At a point in the question and answer session, moderator Karla Porter was asking questions which were not delivered by persons in the live chat. For whatever reason, the chatroom crashed and -- while it was still open -- questions were not easy to read considering the blinding speed of the chat. In the future, we will ask that questions be sent via another medium instead. I appreciate, though, that so many people viewed! Crashing the chatroom is a good sign of interest :)
Information on participants:
Ronda Chervin received a Ph.D. in Philosophy from Fordham University and an MA in Religious Studies from Notre Dame Apostolic Institute. She is a widow, mother, and grandmother. Ronda converted to the Catholic Faith from a Jewish, though atheistic, background and has been a Professor of Philosophy and Theology at Loyola Marymount University, the Seminary of the Archdiocese of Los Angeles, and Franciscan University of Steubenville. She is an international speaker and author of some fifty books about Catholic thought, practice and spirituality. Ronda is currently a Dedicated Widow of the Holy Eucharist forming a small community of dedicated widows. Dr. Ronda is currently teaching philosophy at Holy Apostles College and Seminary in Cromwell, Connecticut. Her website can be found at www.rondachervin.com.
Justin Vacula received bachelor's degrees in Philosophy and Psychology, a minor in Professional Writing, and the distinguished W.A. Kilburn Memorial Award for Philosophy from King's College. Justin Vacula is an outspoken atheist, activist for the separation of church and state, a speaker, writer/reporter, blogger, and host of the NEPA Freethought Society Podcast. He is currently enrolled in Marywood University's graduate-level Mental Health Counseling program. Vacula holds leadership roles as the co-organizer, spokesperson, and a board member of the NEPA Freethought Society. Justin has appeared on various radio shows, television networks, and podcasts. Vacula will be speaking at the upcoming September 28-30 Atheist/Humanist conference in Harrisburg. His website can be found at www.justinvacula.com.
Karla Porter works with organizations that want to achieve employer of choice status, are interested in attracting candidates who will develop into employee brand advocates that drive growth and continued success, embrace diversity, desire a culture of innovation and excellence, want to enrich the community, and reward superior performance with celebrity. Porter is one of four organizers behind the upcoming NEPA BlogCon 2012 conference at Luzerne County Community College taking place on September 29. Her website can be found at www.karlaporter.com.
Debate/Discussion with Pastor John Murray - NEPA Pridefest 2012
I recently had a debate/discussion with Christian fundamentalist Pastor John Murray from Tree of Life Christian Fellowship Church at NEPA Pridefest 2012 (an LGBT festival) in Kingston, PA. Murray and fellow churchgoers arrived to preach to/protest at NEPA Pridefest 2012.
We chatted for about 45 minutes about homosexuality, faith, theological fatalism, free will, the problem of evil, Stephen Law's 'Evil God Challenge,' the Bible, the resurrection of Jesus, miracles, cosmological arguments, the soul, sin, and much more.
Philosopher Stephen Law enjoyed the discussion and you might too.
Enjoy this lively discussion.
William Lane Craig and The Problem of Evil
![]() |
| Prince Prospero from the horror film "The Masque of the Red Death" hints at the problem of evil. |
Christian apologist and popular debater William Lane Craig doesn't think that the problem of evil -- a classic philosophical argument which seeks to undermine belief in the Christian god in light of natural disasters and suffering in the world -- is a problem. Craig has recently given a lecture concerning the problem of suffering and evil at Aalborg University in Denmark. I've watched it and have noticed that his responses to the problem of evil really haven't seemed to change since his debate with philosopher Kai Nielsen in February of 1991. This post will respond to a portion of Craig's opening statement from his 1991 debate and attempt to show why his response to the problem of evil is insufficient.
The problem of evil -- at a very basic understanding -- is well-informed by the above picture. The atheist who points to suffering in the world -- particularly natural disasters and diseases which kill people outright and lead to tremendous suffering -- sees evidence to assume that an all-loving, all-powerful, and all-knowing god (omni-god) does not exist. If an omni-god existed, some reason, it would not have created the universe in such a manner that guarantees natural disasters and diseases kill people and lead to a great deal of suffering. It is not only the case that God permits the disasters, but it is also the case -- as should be noted -- that God, if he exists, designed the universe which contains the disasters.
It also isn't just some suffering that exists, but also an egregious amount of unnecessary suffering. Throughout this post, I'll use the term 'natural disasters' to abbreviate - but it is important to note that much suffering exists because of other factors such as degenerative diseases, mental illness, birth defects, random mutations of genes, and so on. None of what could be considered natural suffering, at least in this case, is the result of human action (and the atheist isn't arguing for God, for example, to intervene in the case of my stubbing a toe or even my driving a car into a tree following a drunken binge).
An argument, then, along the lines of the problem of evil can be formed as follows:
(1) Egregious natural suffering, guaranteed by the natural laws of the universe, exists.Premise one is quite obvious and needs no defense - Christians, even, do not deny premise one, but rather would object to premise two. The atheist can say that God could simply create a universe (and would do so) that is very much unlike ours - one in which an egregious amount of natural suffering does not exist. Why, one wonders, would a god that is all-loving, all-powerful, and all-knowing create this universe? Absent of reasons -- and with the seeming contradiction -- it seems to be the case that an all-powerful, all-loving, and all-knowing god does not exist. I could further elaborate on justification for premise two, but that shouldn't be needed here.
(2) An all-powerful, all-loving, all-knowing god is incompatible with (1).
(3) An all-powerful, all-loving, all-knowing god does not exist.
William Lane Craig, though, as you might expect, objects to premise two. He says, in his 1991 debate,
...we can actually prove that God and evil are logically compatible. You see, the atheist presupposes that God cannot have morally sufficient reasons for permitting the evil in the world. But this assumption is not necessarily true. So long as it is even possible that God has morally sufficient reasons for permitting evil, it follows that God and evil are logically consistent.
What, then, one wonders, could be these morally sufficient reasons that God might have which would show that God and evil are logically consistent? Craig doesn't offer any of these reasons, but rather says,
We are not in a good position to assess the probability of whether God has a morally sufficient reason for the evils that occur: As finite persons, we're limited in space, time, intelligence, and insight, but the omniscient and sovereign God, who sees the end from the beginning, providentially orders history so that His purposes are ultimately achieved through human free decisions. In order to achieve His ends, God may have to put up with evils along the way, which humans freely perpetrate. Evils which appear pointless to us within our limited framework may be seen to be justly permitted within God's wider framework. A brutal murder of an innocent man, for example, could produce a sort of ripple effect throughout history such that God's morally sufficient reason for permitting it might not emerge until centuries later or perhaps in another land. When you think of God's providence over the whole of history, then I think you can see how hopeless it is for limited observers to speculate on the probability that God could have a morally sufficient reason for permitting a particular evil. We're just not in a good position to assess such probabilities.
Note that above, Craig seems to focus on evils which "human freely perpetrate." This, though, is not the thrust (or even the argument) of the problem of evil as far as natural suffering is concerned. What we are dealing with here, or otherwise what seems to be contained in the most forceful argument, is natural suffering.
I have always found Craig's response -- paraphrased to 'we're not in a good position to judge whether God has a sufficient reason for evils that occur' -- to be quite interesting as it seems to be, despite what Craig says (in his above linked lecture), an 'appeal to mystery.' 'For all we know,' Craig seems to assert, 'God might just have a reason.' Absent of finding any sort of reason, seeing the evidence of an egregious amount of natural suffering in this world (and knowing that if the Christian god existed, he could create a world much different than ours), we have all reasons not to believe in the Christian god, it seems.
We understand that, as humans, our knowledge is quite limited. This, though, when dealing with objections to certain beliefs -- in the face of defeaters (reasons to undermine belief) to the beliefs -- shouldn't lead us to simply throw our hands in the air saying something to the effect of, "Well, for all we know..." Knowledge, as it overwhelmingly seems, is based on what we currently know based on observations and reasoning. We hold beliefs, or should hold beliefs, not on what might be, but rather based on what is and what we do know. Absent of reasons that the Christian god might have for designing and permitting an egregious amount of natural suffering, we should be led to the conclusion that the Christian god does not exist - 'natural evil' seems to serve as a defeater to Christian belief.
Craig's position -- and the position of every Christian who maintains that God may, 'for all we know,' have a good reason to design and permit natural suffering -- seems to lead one to the position of, which seems quite interesting in the face of Christians asserting that God is a benevolent being, 'moral agnosticism' or even moral nihilism. If, for all we know, God might have a reason to design and permit natural suffering, natural suffering, after all, might be a wonderful thing. On a Christian accounting, God is an all-loving being...so if God designed an earthquake which had killed hundreds of people, this must be a good thing.
Almost all adults (and children) in the world -- perhaps barring psychopaths -- agree that natural disasters are a terrible, horrible thing. The world would be so much of a better place, it so uncontroversially seems, without natural disasters. This intuition is quite strong and is reflected when persons grieve, donate money to relief efforts, and even try to deter natural disasters. To look at, for example, a tsunami that kills thousands and say, "Well, for all we know this could be a good thing. It might just have been the case that all of those people, for whatever reason, would have been responsible for great moral evils. God might have indeed permitted this, that makes sense" seems to be quite unreasonable - especially when considering the Christian god could achieve whatever 'ends' he desires by different means not including designing the universe with natural disasters.
Is the real concern, though, whether we are in the position to judge that God has no good reasons for permitting and designing natural suffering or, rather, is it the concern that the mere existence of egregious natural suffering poses as a defeater to Christian belief? I think it is the latter and that this whole 'are we in a position' talk is a distraction from the real issue at hand. Either way, it seems to be the case, with the omni-terms that Christians affix to the god they believe in, that we are in a position to judge that God has no reasons for permitting and designing natural suffering - especially in the case of him being able to design a different universe.
As Prince Prospero said in "The Masque of the Red Death," if a god of live ever did exist, he is long since dead (although someone, some thing doesn't seem to rule in its place).
Full audio and some text from my HACS talk
On July 17 of 2012, I appeared as a special guest for a philosophy class titled "Atheism and the New Atheism" for students at Holy Apostles College and Seminary - an evangelical Catholic university in Connecticut. More details are here. I delivered an opening speech and participated in a question and answer session which followed. The entire event lasted one hour and thirteen minutes.
As promised, the full audio of the event was released and has been made available to the public thanks to Dr. Mahfood. Stream the audio here or download the ZIP file here. The audio is unfortunately spotty at points. I may release a re-mastered version of the audio at a later date.
A text version of my speech can be read here:
Holy Apostles College and Seminary Atheism and New Atheism Speech
Timestamps:
(0:00 - 0:25) Introduction by Dr. Mahfood
(0:25 - 0:47) Opening prayer by Dr. Chervin
(0:48 - 1:50) Introduction of Justin Vacula by Dr. Mahfood
(1:50 - 17:50) Opening speech from Justin Vacula
(17:51 - end) Question and answer session
Some of the questions and sentiments (paraphrased) in the question and answer session:
(18:13) Do you use science to determine what is true and false?
(20:33) What good reasons would be sufficient [for you to believe in God]?
(23:30) Do you only believe in something when all the contrary arguments have been resolved?
(27:06) Is there an objective standard for belief or do you have a personal standard?
(29:08) Do you believe something can be universally true?
(30:16) Are you dogmatically opposed, given your commitment to naturalism, to supernatural explanations?
(37:20) Would a supernatural experience lead you to belief in God?
(39:00) Are you looking for hard evidence to believe in God?
(40:52) What about faith?
(42:05) Discussion about the problem of natural evil and omni-attributes
(46:55) Theodicy: This is a fallen world/God's goodness was evident, but is no longer
(49:20) Theodicy: There is a good that supersedes an evil world. Perhaps suffering leads to good beyond this earth? Perhaps suffering is just a prelude to the afterlife?
(52:00) Theodicy: Evil serves a purpose. We see examples in this world in which suffering is required to achieve certain ends.
(54:00) Omni-attributes seem to be a different matter from God existing.
(55:48) Are you an agnostic?
(59:40) Theodicy: Eternal happiness, in light of limited suffering in this world, seems not to be a problem.
(1:01:43) What about metaphysical arguments for God's existence?
(1:04:00) Your philosophical studies seem to start with the Enlightenment. What about before that?
(1:10:45) How do you know that your reason without faith fulfills you?
NEPA Freethought Society Podcast - Episode 11 - Interview with Ethereal Collapse
Episode 11 of the NEPA Freethought Society Podcast is now available in either video or audio format!
Follow this link for the podcast through your method of choice.
Podcast Topic:
Joining us for this podcast -- hailing from Wilkes-Barre, PA -- are members of the melodic death metal band Ethereal Collapse. We discuss themes of philosophy which are present in their music and talk about the band in general.
Cast:
Justin Vacula (Podcast Host, Co-Organizer, Spokesperson, and a Board Member)
Rodney Collins (Founder, Organizer, and Board Chairman)
Jason Gogola (Producer, Web Director, and a Board Member)
If you wish to ask a question or comment on this podcast please send your email to podcast@nepafreethought.org
Ethereal Collapse members on this podcast:
Ryan Klubeck (Guitar, Vocals)
Ken Huber (Guitar)
Nick Durcik (Bass)
Matt Rodriguez (Drums)
Related Links:
Like them on Facebook.
Become a fan on ReverbNation.
View their videos on Youtube.
The vapid Christian response to the death of Tyler Winstead
We believe in God and his master plan - whether we understand it or not.
- God -- an all-loving, all-powerful, and all-knowing being -- includes the shooting death of a 14-year-old boy in his 'master plan.'
- Since God is all-loving, all-powerful, and all-knowing, his 'master plan' should be lauded because only all-good consequences can flow from an all-loving being. (Many Christians, from my experience, have argued or asserted that all judgments or actions stemming from God must accord with his all-loving character)
- Since Tyler Winstead was killed as part of God's plan (and God is all-loving), this is actually -- as much as our moral intuitions may contend -- a good thing. [I'll get more into this later considering a pastor actually states that Tyler "is in the best hands he ever will be.]
I know the plans that I have for you, declares the Lord. They are plans for peace and not disaster.
It's unfortunate that the Citizen's Voice did not include the comments that followed pertaining to that passage: That is is not God's plan that any life should be taken by another and that God intends a hopeful future for all. We are not to allow perpetrators of violent acts to hold us hostage and attempt to deny us a life of peace and justice.
A large number of us have determined to engage with a fierce, and much more powerful weapon, the likes of which no evil has the power to withstand," Brewster said. "We'll employ the weapon of unconditional and radical love for humanity, and out right to live, and not only live, but our right to thrive in a community in peace, in this beautiful valley God has created, in this place we call our home. We intend to preserve it.
he is in the best hands he will ever be.
I want to say to those who are responsible for taking this precious life, I want you to know that despite what you've done, God has and always will love you. And he stands ready to forgive you, should you humble yourself and ask for his forgiveness. Furthermore, it is because of the message of Easter, which brings hope to all mankind, that the family, too, has chosen to love and to forgive you as well.
"Debunked Science" admits of openness, progress
You can't trust scientific findings! Scientists got it wrong so much in the past and what we think was a fact constantly gets overturned! Everything we know today is going to turn out to be wrong in the future. Look at [example x theory or idea]. People thought that was true, but now we know it is not. You can't trust scientists.
“These data show that we are getting substitution across the board,” Wolfe-Simon says. “This microbe, if we are correct, has solved the challenge of being alive in a different way.”“It isn’t about arsenic, and it isn’t about Mono Lake,” says Wolfe-Simon. “There’s something fundamental about understanding the flexibility of life. Any life, a microbe, a tree, you grind it up and it’s going to be CHNOPS. But we have a single sample of life. You can’t look for what you don’t know.”
Philosopher Dr. William Irwin: "Idea that God intervenes in NFL games is absurd"
Recorded Video - Debate: Does the Christian god exist? Rev. Marcelle Dotson vs. Justin Vacula

I debated Rev. Marcelle Dotson of Field of Grace United Methodist Church in Wilkes-Barre on the topic of "Does the Christian god exist?" on December 19, 2011.
The debate was recorded live from "Jason International Studios" in Mountain Top, PA.
The debate is now available as a recorded version for your viewing pleasure. A audio-only podcast will also be available in the near future.
Feel free to comment below, send me e-mail, etc. I'd love to hear from you.
Rev. Dotson's e-mail is mdotson@susumc.org
----
Justin Vacula -- co-organizer, spokesperson, and board member of the NEPA Freethought Society -- graduated from King's College with degrees in Philosophy and Psychology, a distinguished award in Philosophy, and a minor in Professional Writing. He regularly publishes articles for Examiner.com as the 'Scranton Atheism Examiner,' writes for American Atheists' "No God Blog," and publishes posts about “atheism, theism, philosophy, and much more” on his blog at www.justinvacula.com. The NEPA Freethought Society's website can be found at www.nepafreethought.org.
Rev. Marcelle Dotson, pastor of Field of Grace Community of Faith United Methodist Church holds a Bachelor of Arts degree in Psychology from Smith College, a Master's of Divinity degree in Theology from Drew University, and a Master of Business Administration from Simmons School of Management. She served as an associate pastor in Manchester and had served the United Methodist Church in Maine. She came to Wilkes-Barre in 2009 to start Field of Grace. United Methodist Church. The website for her church can be found at www.fieldofgraceumc.org.
The Problem of Evil: Are atheists simply 'asking too much?'

Curtis/Vacula Debate Series "Does the Christian God Exist?" - Compilation Post
Curtis/Vacula Debate Series - Does the Christian God Exist? - Opening Statement
Curtis/Vacula Debate Series - Does the Christian God Exist? - First Rebuttal
Curtis/Vacula Debate Series - Does the Christian God Exist? - Closing Statement
Criticism of "We can't know the mind of God"
"We can't know the mind of God" is a popular theistic smokescreen that utterly fails upon examination.
In several discussions with theists, particularly when the problem of natural evil is the topic of discussion, one of the last defenses of theists, when all of their arguments are seemingly defeated, is "we can't know the mind of God." In a longer form, this typically means something similar to "Our knowledge, when reflecting on what an omniscient being can and does know, is so, so, so slim. To claim that God has no reason for allowing something to happen is so arrogant. How can you claim to know the mind of God? Perhaps God has some reasons that we are unaware of that can justify all of this evil."
Religious of NEPA respond to flooding
God and the NEPA flood
A newscaster on WBRE said "God works in mysterious ways" at 2:47 PM on Friday (10/9/11).
State senator John Yudichak (D) said "Hopefully the good Lord will protect us" on live TV. (Why a state senator is talking about 'the good Lord' on live TV is beyond me.)
Bishop Bambera of the Scranton Diocese said "For all who are suffering because of the flood and the damage it has caused, I pray for God's continued and [sic] protection and blessing over you" among other things.
On the Facebook page titled NEPA flood of 2011, some people have said "God is good. NEPA will get through this." and "The rainbow: signifies Gods promise to never flood the entire globe again (noahs arc). Keep God in your hearts! Hes with us all."
Marcy and Melanie, it is profoundly absurd to posit that after a great deal of our region was absolutely devastated there is an all-loving, all-good, and all-powerful God who exists (I am assuming this is what you believe, but please correct me if I am wrong). 'Natural evil' that is a result of the laws of this universe which you presumably believe God designed is incompatible with an all-loving, all-good, and all-powerful being. If there were an omni-god, one should not expect egregious disasters like this to happen and a planet that is quite hostile to our being. Instead, we see exactly what one would expect if there were no omni-God: natural disasters and a planet that is hostile to our being.
What reasons can an omni-God possibly have for allowing such a disaster like this and more importantly, creating the laws of the universe that dictate natural disasters will happen [I'm not really interested in why he allowed this to happen, but rather why he created the universe in such a manner.]? If you or I were to be omni-powerful and create the a universe, I would wager that this would not be the result from our work. Might it be the case that "God is mysterious," "God's ways are higher than ours," or "There must be some 'greater good' that can only be attained through natural diasters?" All of these defenses fail quite profoundly.
If you believe all three of these things, you should either be happy that our region was devastated (because God is good and logically only good actions would flow from God or otherwise be dictated by him) or descend into utter moral skepticism where you could not say that any action is bad because it might be part of God's plan. Perhaps, to remain consistent, theists should say "Well, this might be part of God's plan, so I can't be angry here and this is needed for my salvation or some other end." This, though, fails when considering an all-good being and an all-powerful being because God could have such 'greater goods' without causing billions of dollars in property damage and killing people.
Melanie, if God were good, this disaster would have never happened in the first place.
Marcy, if God really were with us all, don't you think that this should have never happened in the first place or that he would stop it? If I had a personal relationship with you, loved you, loved humanity, were all-good, all-powerful, and all-knowing, designed the universe, etc, I would never have designed the universe in such a manner and if I did for some reason (which would make no sense), I would have stopped this flood. Imagine, by analogy, that there was some sort of superhero in NEPA who can, at a finger snap, magically cause the flood waters to go down and have prevented this flood. God, presumably, can do this and much more. If this superhero were in NEPA and he did nothing to stop the flood, we would consider him/her to be an utter monster...so why not consider God to be a monster, rebuke God, etc? Why make the excuses?
This disaster clearly showed us that faith proved nothing concerning this flood. All of the prayers in the world/this region did nothing to stop this flooding and other natural disasters. What really mattered, though, was the effort of humans, minus any supernatural concerns, to help their neighbors, report the news, build the levees, sandbag, etc.


